To the best of my knowledge, what differentiates the 52j / 54j / 56j is the bell diameter -- 52j is 18", 54j is 19", and 56j is 20".Pons wrote:... I have looked at a few Conn tubas, the 5xj variety, what is the difference between the 52j/54j and 56j? It seems like the have the same specifications and such.
BBb and CC tubas
-
Kevin Hendrick
- 6 valves
- Posts: 3156
- Joined: Sat Sep 25, 2004 10:51 pm
- Location: Location: Location
"Don't take life so serious, son. It ain't nohow permanent." -- Pogo (via Walt Kelly)
-
TubaingAgain
- bugler
- Posts: 75
- Joined: Wed May 02, 2007 2:35 pm
- Location: Sarasota,Fl
-
The Big Ben
- 6 valves
- Posts: 3169
- Joined: Sat Dec 16, 2006 11:54 am
- Location: Port Townsend, WA
Has anyone here blown a Norwegian Star? The advertising says it's great but I haven't heard about practical experience.Doc wrote: Bob, our local eefer cheerleader, is not off the mark about Eb horns, despite the misconception among tubists that a player should only play CC and F. A large Eb like the Willson 3400 or the Meinl Weston 2141 are probably horns that are true do-it-all-if-I-could-only-own-one-horn horns.
-
Steve Inman
- 4 valves
- Posts: 804
- Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 11:48 am
Contact DanClouse on this forum to get his opinions on his MW2141 Eb. It's working very well for him in a number of situations.
Post above is correct re: Conn models 52, 54, 56J -- only difference is bell diamter and associated breadth of sound.
If you're only going to have one tuba, the conventional wisdom is to get a 4/4 size. Or a large 4/4 size. The Miraphone 187 BBb or 188 CC, or the 1291/2 CC all fit this bill. Tubists are about the only folks who want a smaller sound for quintet, with exception of a few pros who really care about the character of the blend. My experience with amateur groups and amateur audiences is that a bigger tuba isn't a liability in a quintet. But a smaller tuba can be a challenge in an orchestral setting. Just my observation. For the best of both worlds, get a used YEB-321 Eb for your quintet horn (modestly priced) and a used 188/1291-2 for your larger horn. Probably a bit higher than $8K, but then you've got a choice.
As an adult amateur playing quintet, community concert band, brass choir (15pc), pit orchestras, church orchestras, my 20" bell Conn 56J is the horn I typically use. If it were a 54J or 52J, I think it would be a little better choice for the quintet setting, but otherwise, it works okay all around. I believe the 1292 CC would be an even better choice for my playing situations.
Good luck,
Post above is correct re: Conn models 52, 54, 56J -- only difference is bell diamter and associated breadth of sound.
If you're only going to have one tuba, the conventional wisdom is to get a 4/4 size. Or a large 4/4 size. The Miraphone 187 BBb or 188 CC, or the 1291/2 CC all fit this bill. Tubists are about the only folks who want a smaller sound for quintet, with exception of a few pros who really care about the character of the blend. My experience with amateur groups and amateur audiences is that a bigger tuba isn't a liability in a quintet. But a smaller tuba can be a challenge in an orchestral setting. Just my observation. For the best of both worlds, get a used YEB-321 Eb for your quintet horn (modestly priced) and a used 188/1291-2 for your larger horn. Probably a bit higher than $8K, but then you've got a choice.
As an adult amateur playing quintet, community concert band, brass choir (15pc), pit orchestras, church orchestras, my 20" bell Conn 56J is the horn I typically use. If it were a 54J or 52J, I think it would be a little better choice for the quintet setting, but otherwise, it works okay all around. I believe the 1292 CC would be an even better choice for my playing situations.
Good luck,
Steve Inman
Yamaha YEB-381 Eb
Conn 56J CC
Willson-Marzan CC Solo Model
Kokomo Chamber Brass
Yamaha YEB-381 Eb
Conn 56J CC
Willson-Marzan CC Solo Model
Kokomo Chamber Brass
-
Wyvern
- Wessex Tubas
- Posts: 5033
- Joined: Fri Sep 01, 2006 7:00 pm
- Location: Hampshire, England when not travelling around the world on Wessex business
- Contact:
The 2040/5 Eb can certainly be used for symphonic use - I have mine more than once.
I am currently using for concert Berlioz Corsair/Verdi Requiem, but have previously used for Mahler 6 and Elgar 2 (where I was even asked by the conductor to back off
).
If you just do occasional orchestral and mainly smaller ensemble, then one would be an idea all-purpose tuba. However, if mainly playing in larger ensembles, then a 4/4 CC would I think be the better option.
I am currently using for concert Berlioz Corsair/Verdi Requiem, but have previously used for Mahler 6 and Elgar 2 (where I was even asked by the conductor to back off
).If you just do occasional orchestral and mainly smaller ensemble, then one would be an idea all-purpose tuba. However, if mainly playing in larger ensembles, then a 4/4 CC would I think be the better option.
-
Leland
- pro musician
- Posts: 1651
- Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 11:54 am
- Location: Washington, DC
Here's the problem with checking intonation --Pons wrote:Also I am new to trying out tubas, I've usually used school instruments which I believe were the VMI 3301 and Mira. 1291. Specifically what notes should I look at to determine (as a litmus test) if the specific tuba has "ideal intonation"? Would it be the F just below the staff on Bb's? or Would you recommend just going through the notes that have given me consistent intonation trouble in the past?
Consciously or not, you'll be in the habit (hopefully, anyway) of correcting the intonation of the horn you've been playing on the most... and those corrections are likely to be different than what would be needed on a horn that you're trying out for the first time. You'll end up seeing "good intonation" on a horn that has the same tendencies of the one you already use while seeing "worse" intonation on a horn that has different tendencies.
Put another way -- some of those habitual corrections may throw another horn's notes out of whack, while a player who's already owned that other horn finds it easy to play in tune.
The best you can do, then, is to not overanalyze what you'll find with a tuner. See if as many notes as possible play pretty close to in tune, but don't get crazy about it and write down, say, which horns play which notes so-and-so cents off. If some don't easily tune, see how they respond to alternate fingerings, slide adjustments, or even a bit of embouchure tweaking.
-
Leland
- pro musician
- Posts: 1651
- Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 11:54 am
- Location: Washington, DC
LOL... I don't know why I didn't spot that before...Greg wrote:You know, if I had typed this, someone would have most certainly thrown out a snide remark or said something about "duck sausage".The Big Ben wrote: Has anyone here blown a Norwegian Star? The advertising says it's great but I haven't heard about practical experience.
-
The Big Ben
- 6 valves
- Posts: 3169
- Joined: Sat Dec 16, 2006 11:54 am
- Location: Port Townsend, WA
Uh, I'm in the dark....Leland wrote:LOL... I don't know why I didn't spot that before...Greg wrote:You know, if I had typed this, someone would have most certainly thrown out a snide remark or said something about "duck sausage".The Big Ben wrote: Has anyone here blown a Norwegian Star? The advertising says it's great but I haven't heard about practical experience.
Better just leave me here....