Mr Standman:
http://www.misterstandman.com/thestnds.htm



Nothing wrong at all with the clef displayed on the lower photo.tubafreaks7 wrote:The top one is absolutely beautiful. Can anyone point out the flaw in the staff stand?
answer:
The two dots are supposed to sandwitch the F line, not the D. Even so, they are still pretty sweet.

The idea of Joe also struck me when seeing Paul S’s lower photo. But as trained in semiotics I take similar signs as expressing the same sort of semantic value. If the uppermost "barline" is only there to secure the stability of the frame, then it should have had a with different from the "real" barlines and/or it should have had some decorative carvings.bloke wrote:On the treble clef stand, the bottom of the bottom space determines the bottom line of the staff. Perhaps that is what is intended here as well.

Thank you for the link, Paul -- those are very impressive and beautiful stands.Paul S wrote:... I have no clue who the maker is beyond the web site but I thought I would share the find as I always appreciate fine craftsmanship in this day of age ...
Mr Standman:
http://www.misterstandman.com/thestnds.htm
And thanks to you too, Klaus -- interesting page! I've run across some of that information before, but not all of it, and not all in one place. Much appreciated.

I tend to agree with your assumption. I even tend to find it a wise decision, when it comes to securing the stability of the back frame.bloke wrote:I just think the guy has set himself a limit on the bottom of the backrest on just how low he will allow holes to occur in the backrest.

I think that this is the point. I expect that these are meant to be functional stands with some decorative value. They are not meant to be an exact representation of a treble or bass clef, other than in the shape of the clef sign.imperialbari wrote:I tend to agree with your assumption. I even tend to find it a wise decision, when it comes to securing the stability of the back frame.bloke wrote:I just think the guy has set himself a limit on the bottom of the backrest on just how low he will allow holes to occur in the backrest.
...
Klaus