Page 1 of 1
replacing the bell on a CB50
Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2006 12:35 pm
by me
my Cb50 has just met with a bit of tragedy and, long story short, i need to either repair or replace my bell. I've heard of people using carbon fiber bells and also the bells off of monster Eb tubas. Does anyone know of a person (preferably in or around the south east) who does these kinds of jobs? i know the carbon fiber bells are probably few and far between, but i assume that there are a good number of other options out there.
Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2006 1:05 pm
by Tom
A York Monster Eb bell would be a nice alternative, thought finding a "good" one without having to buy the whole horn just for the bell (which you could do, I suppose) might be difficult...I dunno. One of the regular posters here has a G-50 with a York Monster Eb bell. I think a lot of the "york sound" has to do with the bell.
I'd look past carbon fiber. Yeah, it's unusual and it might be fun to tout having a carbon fiber bell, but not only are they very difficult to find and have installed, the sound can be compared to playing a brass sousaphone with a brass bell and then playing the same brass sousaphone with a fiberglass bell.
Some years ago, while I had a CB-50, I spoke with (reportedly) the only person (just can't remember who that was) to actually have a carbon fiber bell on a G-50 other than Chuck Daellenbach, and his feelings were that although it was a neat novelty item, brass bells sounded better.
If you REALLY want to pursue the carbon fiber bell thing, look for George McCracken. Last I knew he was in Virginia. He is the guy that made the carbon fiber bells (and later a carbon fiber mouthpipe) for Chuck Daellenbach's G-50s.
Also, Andy Kochenour in the Dixie Power Trio had a B&M with a carbon fiber bell...about all I know about it though.
Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2006 1:12 pm
by UDELBR
Call Meinl-Weston (Melton). They made the original bells; they've still got the mandrels, and are still willing to make 'em. +49 8171 92187-19
Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2006 1:13 pm
by Chuck(G)
Don't overlook Holton and King monster Eb bells, which will also fit. The King has a 20" bell, instead of a 19+" bell like the Holton and York, but otherwise fits the same bottom bow.
There may be others--the "monster" Eb design was very popular.