Posted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 10:15 pm
Because of the interaction of the mouthpiece cup, throat and backbore, there is no good way to predict how a mouthpiece will or will not perform on a given tuba, so in the end, you'll just have to try one. If you like the diameter and the rim shape of your Schilke, then here is a mouthpiece chart to get you in the same ballpark with mouthpieces of similar dimensions:
http://www.ibowtie.com/tubampccharts.html
That said, take my experience with a grain of salt: On my Besson with the small receiver, I use the Wick 1 small shank designed for it. My Bach 18, which has the standard American shank, only goes in @ 1/2 inch, effectively lengthening the horn @ 1 inch. But playing with my Bach 18 I have the same relative pitch as with the Wick 1, which has a really deep funnel cup, but roughly the same throat diameter. I do not adjust my tuning slide when going between the two.
A friend in Shrine band has a relatively newer M-W bell model, and uses an old Conn 2, and always complains about how far he has to pull his slide out. But since the German companies also make a lot of their horns at A=443 unless you specifically ask for the A=440 tuning, I have always chalked it off to his horn. But now I wonder.
http://www.ibowtie.com/tubampccharts.html
That said, take my experience with a grain of salt: On my Besson with the small receiver, I use the Wick 1 small shank designed for it. My Bach 18, which has the standard American shank, only goes in @ 1/2 inch, effectively lengthening the horn @ 1 inch. But playing with my Bach 18 I have the same relative pitch as with the Wick 1, which has a really deep funnel cup, but roughly the same throat diameter. I do not adjust my tuning slide when going between the two.
A friend in Shrine band has a relatively newer M-W bell model, and uses an old Conn 2, and always complains about how far he has to pull his slide out. But since the German companies also make a lot of their horns at A=443 unless you specifically ask for the A=440 tuning, I have always chalked it off to his horn. But now I wonder.