Does PDQ Bach...
Posted: Wed May 23, 2007 11:15 am
have anything for brass quintet available?
Thanks
Thanks
I would have to disagree. I think that the "Polka" works great on its own and is quite humorous. It is difficult music to put together, but it's a real crowd pleaser. I have used it many times with great success. If you want to go all out, stage the whole thing. It's a real gas! Have fun with it!the elephant wrote:The "Polka" from Hornsmoke is credited to Peret Schickele and not PDQ Bach. It is not funny. If you purchase it thinking that it will be a bunch of laughs you will be disappointed. It has an odd, recurring 3/4 bar and some blatty long notes in one trumpet part. But you need to have the costumes, choreography and narration for any of that to make any sense or be even mildly funny to the audience. If you do it as a straight polka you will have these weird notes in the trumpet and a recurring odd meter bar to explain to the listeners . . . along with its non-melodic melody.
Unfortunately, we play this all of the time. It needs to be played in its proper context or not at all.
The Canadian Brass did the whole Hornsmoke thing in their video production called "Spectacular". It's available on the CB website, but I don't find it at Amazon. That video also includes a performance of Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis arranged for triple quintet, played with the New York Phil and Boston Symphony brass quintets, and conducted by Georg Tintner. It's worth finding for that alone.the elephant wrote:However, I have seen a bootleg of a sort of dress rehearsal of Hornsmoke, and within that context it is a good piece. I have never heard of these guys actually performing Hornsmoke live. I am not sure that they ever did. It is a fairly funny spoof of Gunsmoke but did not seem to be as well written as, say, the ballet skit. They probably only did it for a single season, a long time ago. This bootleg was from around 1979 I am guessing by the late-disco era tuxes under the "costumes" that they are wearing.
I saw Hornsmoke performed live in Denver about four or five years ago (time flies). Daellenbach played portions of it lying on his back. The group was in fine form.the elephant wrote: . . . . I have never heard of these guys actually performing Hornsmoke live. I am not sure that they ever did. It is a fairly funny spoof of Gunsmoke but did not seem to be as well written as, say, the ballet skit. They probably only did it for a single season, a long time ago. This bootleg was from around 1979 I am guessing by the late-disco era tuxes under the "costumes" that they are wearing.
The Polka comes between the square dance and "Introduction and Tango" on the Chestnut CD. I tend to view the Chestnut Brass version as being definitive, as it uses Schickele as the narrator.Rick Denney wrote:I own and have performed the Polka, supposedly from Hornsmoke. But I could not find that work in the Canadian Brass performance of Hornsmoke, at least not as a complete work.