"American" vs. "German" tubas

The bulk of the musical talk
User avatar
Wyvern
Wessex Tubas
Wessex Tubas
Posts: 5033
Joined: Fri Sep 01, 2006 7:00 pm
Location: Hampshire, England when not travelling around the world on Wessex business
Contact:

Post by Wyvern »

tuba kitchen wrote:so, next question: which larger Eb (thinking of willson 3400 or MW 2141) would have a "german" sound and would fit into a german orchestra???
Definitely the MW 2040/5 has a German F tuba sound. It was designed specifically with that sound in mind (using a PT-65 mouthpiece).

I have had the chance to play test and compare side by side with a MW 45 and a B&S PT-15 F and the tone from the 2040/5 is midway between those two. The 45 is slightly broader, while the PT-15 is slightly leaner in tone.

I have also played the F tuba part in an Austrian band on my 2040/5 and its tone matched perfect.

Jonathan "who thinks the tone of a Besson EEb is nearer to a 4/4 CC"
Tubanese
bugler
bugler
Posts: 88
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 6:19 pm

Post by Tubanese »

so...is the MW2141 has a German sound or the "Meinl Weston" sound? I think it has its traditional MW sound. (JMO)
Meinl Weston 2165(Prototype)
Meinl Weston 45SLZ
Meinl Weston Bill Bell Model(Original)
Holton 345
Holton "Monster Bb"
User avatar
iiipopes
Utility Infielder
Utility Infielder
Posts: 8556
Joined: Tue Sep 06, 2005 1:10 am

Post by iiipopes »

As you can see, I tend to diversity, as all have their place, and application.
Jupiter JTU1110, RT-82.
"Real" Conn 36K.
User avatar
Rick Denney
Resident Genius
Posts: 6650
Joined: Mon Mar 22, 2004 1:18 am
Contact:

Post by Rick Denney »

iiipopes wrote:As you can see, I tend to diversity, as all have their place, and application.
Me, too. My stable:

Holton BB-345 (American, by definition)
York Master (American in inspiration, but Germanic in execution)
Miraphone 186 (Sprechen sie Deutsch?)
Martin TU-31 (There's no place like plastic home)

B&S Symphonie F (as German as it gets, in a Marxist sort of a way)
Yamaha YFB-621 (as Bloke accurately observed, British to the core, except for the "Made in Japan" bit)

Rick "horses for courses and all that" Denney
User avatar
pwhitaker
3 valves
3 valves
Posts: 449
Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 1:58 pm
Location: Springvale, Maine

Better late than never ...

Post by pwhitaker »

Up until 2006 I played all "American" or "British" horns (since 1952 or so) according to the classifications offered by the savants in this thread. I acquired an old (197x) Miraphone 186 BBb 4v with recording bell and immediately fell in love with its tone, projection and intonation. I then got the tuba equipment bug (having gone 15 years without buying any horns) and bought a brand new 1291 5v BBb which I was totally besotted with for about 11 months. An old 5/4 Rudy BBb became available and needless to say, it was love at first note. I sent the 1291 down to Dillons if anyone is interested in a good 5v BBb with an MTS case and an extra 2/3 5th valve slide. The point of this little ramble is that I am completely enamored with the "German" sound. Walter Hilger is a demi-god.
MISERICORDE, n.
A dagger which in mediaeval warfare was used by the foot soldier to remind an unhorsed knight that he was mortal.
- Devil's Dictionary - Ambrose Bierce
TheTuba
3 valves
3 valves
Posts: 368
Joined: Sun Dec 10, 2017 9:02 pm

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by TheTuba »

I play a mira 186. Can I get a "american sound"? I sound too piercing in band according to my band director (she says I am louder than the trombones)(our trombones suck).
I would put a good signature here, but i dont have one, so this will make do.
TheTuba
3 valves
3 valves
Posts: 368
Joined: Sun Dec 10, 2017 9:02 pm

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by TheTuba »

I use a RT-44
I would put a good signature here, but i dont have one, so this will make do.
User avatar
Ken Crawford
4 valves
4 valves
Posts: 722
Joined: Sat Jun 23, 2012 10:45 am
Location: Rexburg, ID

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by Ken Crawford »

bloke wrote:bump
8)
User avatar
bigtubby
4 valves
4 valves
Posts: 747
Joined: Mon Jan 07, 2013 9:43 pm
Location: Ohio

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by bigtubby »

Meh, I'll take an ancient Bohemian sousaphone (in the right hands of course) any day ...
http://youtu.be/NWIgDTHdtKc
American sailboats, airplanes, banjos, guitars and flutes ...
Italian motorcycles and cars ...
German cameras and tubas ...
Life is Good.
User avatar
ken k
6 valves
6 valves
Posts: 2369
Joined: Sun Mar 21, 2004 11:02 pm
Location: out standing in my field....

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by ken k »

TheTuba wrote:I play a mira 186. Can I get a "american sound"? I sound too piercing in band according to my band director (she says I am louder than the trombones)(our trombones suck).
try a Helleberg style mouthpiece...
Yamaha YEB-381
Mirafone 187 BBb
1919 Pan American BBb Helicon
1924 Buescher BBb tuba (Dr. Suessaphone)
Black plastic Coolwind BBb tuba
2001 Mazda Miata
2006 Suzuki Burgman 650
TheTuba
3 valves
3 valves
Posts: 368
Joined: Sun Dec 10, 2017 9:02 pm

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by TheTuba »

Tried funnels, I suck on them. Plus I don't like the bite. I don't want to change mouthpieces, just the sound.
I would put a good signature here, but i dont have one, so this will make do.
User avatar
ken k
6 valves
6 valves
Posts: 2369
Joined: Sun Mar 21, 2004 11:02 pm
Location: out standing in my field....

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by ken k »

I have been dealing with this issue in my own playing recently.

For 30+ years I have played a Boosey & Hawkes Imperial Eb with a 19"bell. It has a very "broad" tone. I always enjoyed its full and rich sound. I would liken this to the "American" style. A small bore horn with a large bell, which diffuses the sound a bit. For the past few years I was trying to get a more focused sound, (since I play the top Eb part in a brass band) so I started using a bowl style mouthpiece as opposed a Helleberg style (I used a conn Helleberg on the horn for probably 15 years.)

About a year ago I purchased a Miraphone Norwegian Star Eb, and the tone is much more focused (German?), like a scalpel as opposed to a butter knife. It would be a larger bore horn but with a smaller bell (more cylindrical overall than the Boosey?) I have been experimenting with which mouthpiece to use. I have a number of Sellmanberger cups to interchange with my rim (the older 2 piece models, Imperial, Symphony, Solo # 1 & 2, also regular and mega rims). I seem to have settled in on the Solo #2 with the mega (deep) rim, so I have a bowl cup, but a bit deeper. I find when I use the Sellmansberger Symphony, which is a deep funnel, the horn definitely loses some of that edge and has a broader tone. When I play with the pops Orchestra I think I may use the Symphony cup to help broaden the tone a bit for the larger ensemble. I would be curious how much this difference is actually heard out in the audience??? Or is it a matter of feel vs. sound?

I also prefer the more focused sound with my quintet. It just gives me a more precise tone and articulation, which I like in the quintet (for now, anyway, maybe in a year I will wish for the fuller sound again, who knows.)

Norwegian Star vs. Boosey Imperial (Besson), definitley two different style horns, two distinct sounds. Which is better? A matter of taste I would guess. Do you like a German accent or an English accent?
Yamaha YEB-381
Mirafone 187 BBb
1919 Pan American BBb Helicon
1924 Buescher BBb tuba (Dr. Suessaphone)
Black plastic Coolwind BBb tuba
2001 Mazda Miata
2006 Suzuki Burgman 650
User avatar
Ken Crawford
4 valves
4 valves
Posts: 722
Joined: Sat Jun 23, 2012 10:45 am
Location: Rexburg, ID

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by Ken Crawford »

bloke wrote:What is the proper mouthpiece to use with a Chinese copy of a Japanese copy of a German copy of a one-off American tuba?

Image

Obviously.
User avatar
Fergie
bugler
bugler
Posts: 24
Joined: Mon Apr 30, 2018 3:00 pm

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by Fergie »

Wait, do English tubas have a particular "sound"?
Dvorak probably wrote the the fourteen notes in New World Symphony to get his tuba friends a gig.
Patrase
bugler
bugler
Posts: 149
Joined: Fri Jun 27, 2014 5:02 pm

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by Patrase »

Would James Gourlay playing his recordings of 'British Tuba Concertos' be the British tuba sound? He seems to be a Besson artist and a well regarded UK tuba player told me James uses a 24 equivalent mouthpeice. So am guessing that's what equipment the album was recorded with.
Miraphone Norwegian Star
Yamaha YBB-632 Bb Neo
User avatar
kontrabasstuba
3 valves
3 valves
Posts: 329
Joined: Tue Nov 17, 2015 4:40 am
Location: Germany

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by kontrabasstuba »

The most traditional german Bb tuba sound was and is the 6/4 Bohland and Fuchs(or other old instrument builder from Graslitz and surrounding area)
Lots big tubas (upright mainslide) based on this type and body form. Amazing and unequaled sound. :tuba:
User avatar
Wyvern
Wessex Tubas
Wessex Tubas
Posts: 5033
Joined: Fri Sep 01, 2006 7:00 pm
Location: Hampshire, England when not travelling around the world on Wessex business
Contact:

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by Wyvern »

Patrase wrote:Would James Gourlay playing his recordings of 'British Tuba Concertos' be the British tuba sound? He seems to be a Besson artist and a well regarded UK tuba player told me James uses a 24 equivalent mouthpeice. So am guessing that's what equipment the album was recorded with.
I would say John Fletcher playing a Besson 19” bell compensated EEb tuba provides the classic British tuba sound. At least that is the sound a lot of us tuba players in the UK aspire
TheTuba
3 valves
3 valves
Posts: 368
Joined: Sun Dec 10, 2017 9:02 pm

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by TheTuba »

other than American, German, and British tonal colors, Is there any other regional tonal characteristic that is seperate from these and followed by many people?

Also, With the Advent of more tuba players, will a new "Asian" sound begin to emerge?

Finally, other than the more Cylindrical (Miraphone) tubas (German), and the more broad Conical/very fast increasing bell diameter (King 2341) tubas (American), will a new design emerge that complements the above mentioned "Asian" sound?


With the new players, the tuba world is getting more exciting..........
I would put a good signature here, but i dont have one, so this will make do.
TheTuba
3 valves
3 valves
Posts: 368
Joined: Sun Dec 10, 2017 9:02 pm

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by TheTuba »

Would the newer 186 miraphone be a American tuba or a Germanic tuba?
Also, would the wessex luzern be considered a german or american?
Finally, what are some tubas that are American but use valves?
One more question I promise!
Off topic, but are most piston American horns like the king 2341's? I recall that some notes were stuffy/ loud ( looking at you, B and C) on that horn, that's why I steered clear of pistons from then on.

EDIT: when I say American and german, I mean the American and German styles of tubas
I would put a good signature here, but i dont have one, so this will make do.
Bnich93
bugler
bugler
Posts: 120
Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 8:39 pm

Re: "American" vs. "German" tubas

Post by Bnich93 »

TheTuba, you really should lurk more or use google to find out these things. Even though it is forgivable considering you are a beginner to the tuba world, some of these questions do not make a ton of sense and you tend to relate features of tubas to the sounds that they make even though 99% of tone is coming from the players themselves.

Now to actually answer some of the questions:

"With the Advent of more tuba players, will a new "Asian" sound begin to emerge?"
Only if they start designing their own tubas rather than copying aspects of other companies horns.

"Finally, other than the more Cylindrical (Miraphone) tubas (German), and the more broad Conical/very fast increasing bell diameter (King 2341) tubas (American), will a new design emerge that complements the above mentioned "Asian" sound?"
No.

"Would the newer 186 miraphone be a American tuba or a Germanic tuba?"
German

"would the wessex luzern be considered a german or american?"
German

"Finally, what are some tubas that are American but use valves?"
All of them.

"are most piston American horns like the king 2341"
No, and I found the 2341 to be a very free blowing horn in my experience. I don't understand why you think that the pistons contributed to a different sound quality and that they should be avoided on other horns because of one experience.
Hirsbrunner HB50 w/Warburton 30DL
John Packer 377s w/Parker Cantabile
Post Reply