Here is a shot of two French Eb tuba pistons--both about the same 0.620-ish bore size. Note that the top-sprung one is about a third again as tall as the bottom-sprung one.
The very tall valve casings might well explain why we don't see them on tubas more often:
why bottom-loading valves?
- Chuck(G)
- 6 valves
- Posts: 5676
- Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 12:48 am
- Location: Not out of the woods yet.
- Contact:
- Dan Schultz
- TubaTinker
- Posts: 10424
- Joined: Thu Mar 18, 2004 10:46 pm
- Location: Newburgh, Indiana
- Contact:
Re: .
Hey, Chuck! I don't understand your post. It seems to me that the casing would be roughly the same length because the spring has to be someplace, doesn't it?Chuck(G) wrote:Here is a shot of two French Eb tuba pistons--both about the same 0.620-ish bore size. Note that the top-sprung one is about a third again as tall as the bottom-sprung one.
The very tall valve casings might well explain why we don't see them on tubas more often:
I think the best reason for tubas not using top-springs is that it would increase the piston weight to a point where it would affect the piston travel speed adversely.
Dan Schultz
"The Village Tinker"
http://www.thevillagetinker.com" target="_blank
Current 'stable'... Rudolf Meinl 5/4, Marzan (by Willson) euph, King 2341, Alphorn, and other strange stuff.
"The Village Tinker"
http://www.thevillagetinker.com" target="_blank
Current 'stable'... Rudolf Meinl 5/4, Marzan (by Willson) euph, King 2341, Alphorn, and other strange stuff.
- Chuck(G)
- 6 valves
- Posts: 5676
- Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 12:48 am
- Location: Not out of the woods yet.
- Contact:
Re: .
Nope, consider:TubaTinker wrote:Hey, Chuck! I don't understand your post. It seems to me that the casing would be roughly the same length because the spring has to be someplace, doesn't it?
- The space under the piston iin the casing's going to be pretty much the same, since the piston has to move through the same distance in either model. Most of the compressed length of the spring in the bottom-sprung version will be tucked into the recess in the bottom of the piston.
- However, take a look at the spring and its housing on top of the piston. The casing has to be large enough to contain the piston and the housing. And we can't do away with the housing since we're still compressing the spring contained therein on the downstroke. If we were stretching the spring on the downstroke, then the top- and bottom-sprung versions could be the same size.
- Dan Schultz
- TubaTinker
- Posts: 10424
- Joined: Thu Mar 18, 2004 10:46 pm
- Location: Newburgh, Indiana
- Contact:
Re: .
OK... I'll kinda give you that one. However, I still say that the major problem is the piston weight. All that stuff on top of the top-loaded spring adds a lot of mass.... OK for small pistons but deadly for tuba-sized pistons.Chuck(G) wrote:Nope, consider:TubaTinker wrote:Hey, Chuck! I don't understand your post. It seems to me that the casing would be roughly the same length because the spring has to be someplace, doesn't it?
Hope this makes sense.
- The space under the piston iin the casing's going to be pretty much the same, since the piston has to move through the same distance in either model. Most of the compressed length of the spring in the bottom-sprung version will be tucked into the recess in the bottom of the piston.
- However, take a look at the spring and its housing on top of the piston. The casing has to be large enough to contain the piston and the housing. And we can't do away with the housing since we're still compressing the spring contained therein on the downstroke. If we were stretching the spring on the downstroke, then the top- and bottom-sprung versions could be the same size.
Dan Schultz
"The Village Tinker"
http://www.thevillagetinker.com" target="_blank
Current 'stable'... Rudolf Meinl 5/4, Marzan (by Willson) euph, King 2341, Alphorn, and other strange stuff.
"The Village Tinker"
http://www.thevillagetinker.com" target="_blank
Current 'stable'... Rudolf Meinl 5/4, Marzan (by Willson) euph, King 2341, Alphorn, and other strange stuff.
- Leland
- pro musician
- Posts: 1651
- Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 11:54 am
- Location: Washington, DC
How about:
To fit the same travel in my Nirschl-built 3302's pistons by using top springs instead of the original bottom ones, they would have to extend from the instrument over an inch further than they already do.
That's not necessarily a problem for playing, but it would be scary when I'm walking around a band room or through a doorway.
To fit the same travel in my Nirschl-built 3302's pistons by using top springs instead of the original bottom ones, they would have to extend from the instrument over an inch further than they already do.
That's not necessarily a problem for playing, but it would be scary when I'm walking around a band room or through a doorway.
- Matt G
- 5 valves
- Posts: 1196
- Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 9:24 am
- Location: Quahog, RI
In a past life, when I played trumpet, I owned that student model Yamaha Flugel. I had friends who had all of the "good" flugels (Benge, Courtois, Yamaha 6XX and 7XX series). Once they played my YFL-2XX, they were blown away.bloke wrote: A customer of mine (who is known world-wide for playing Japanese-made gold-plated trumpets) actually prefers his "student" Japanese flugelhorn (horizontal slides / top-sprung pistons) to his "professional" gold-plated Japanese flugelhorn (vertical slides with triggers / bottom-sprung valves). If you have an idea to whom I'm referring, this instrument was given to him when he was seven years old...(so if you want to play a wind instrument as well as some of these young protégé string players, starting to play just as early as they do may be one of the untapped secrets).
- Better intonation.
- Freer blowing.
- More flexible sound.
- Easier "switch".
If I were to ever buy another Flugel, thet would top it the list.
BTW, the valves do make a significant difference in the feel. This was just an additional benefit from this model. Again, this made it an easier "switch" not only because of the blow, but the ergonomics and tactile feeling of playing and using the horn.
Dillon/Walters CC
Meinl Weston 2165
Meinl Weston 2165