TubeNet

I'm not a tuba player, and I won't be able to give you any advice on specific models, but you might want to try checking classifieds around your area for used tubas also. You might get lucky. Also, if you're worried about inconsistant horns, you could give Roger Lewis a call at Woodwind and Brasswind. I called up asking about euphoniums, and said that I was worried because I'd like to play them to choose the best one, and he said he could play all of the ones in stock and choose the best to send out. He sounded like a very honest guy, and I think if you tell him your situation, he would help you out. Good luck!

For Dixieland uses, this horn looks pretty interesting, and should only cost you a grand. It is that latest creation from Harv of Harv's Happy Horns.
Conn 12J with a 20K valveset and 24" bell. If I didn't already have my Martin, I would consider it myself.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vi ... 97023&rd=1

I'd be more interested if the bell were cut down to about 16-18 inches.

Paul (who isn't impressed by grotesque bell flares)

geraldus wrote:So, my main question at this point is: in the 3k price range, which tuba, if any (VMI-2103, Cerveny 686, Allora 186, etc) has the most reliable workmanship?

Of the ones you mention, the VMI would be my first choice for an instrument with predictable quality. If you buy from a good dealer, though (and in that list I would include well-regarded player-sellers like Tony Clements, Roger Lewis, Dave Fedderly, and Matt Walters), they can help you filter out an instrument that might not be good for you.

There are indeed other options to consider. For a little more, you can get a King 2341, which is a great tuba. And for that amount, you can get a used Miraphone 186 in excellent condition, and have even more predictability than any of the above new instruments. Miraphones are about as consistent as it gets.

Rick "who thinks a used Miraphone, well cared for, never declines in value" Denney

I've been playing on a 681 for a few years now, however these were older cerveny's (I believe they are about 10 yrs or so old).

My director ordered a brand new 686 recently, which we are currently waiting for it to arrive. I'll let you know how it plays in comparison to, what I think, is a very good horn for the money (the 681 I play). To me, the horn is free blowing and i've had no problems playing in tune or playing anything that has been required of me thus far. I have however heard new cerveny's can be inconsistent as far as quality goes which is why im anxious to recieve the 686 and begin playing on it to compare it to the 681 I've currently been playing for years.

Though, If I could I'd buy a used 186 in good condition over a new cerveny. Just because I think the 186 is a better horn all around, as well, if the person you buy from is honest you'll have a better chance of getting a guarenteed to be good horn.

I have had a good experience with Dave Fedderly at Baltimore Brass Co. He is a great guy and is really helpful. Baltimore Brass has an advert on tubenet.

My 0.08 bits

Sousie

Save a little long so you can make the trip. It'll be more than worth it. By the time you ship a tuba and case, a few time trying to find a horn you like, you would have payed for the trip (probaby).
Where are you in Canada? If you're withing a days drive of a shop, make the trip. I think you'll be glad you did.