Hi all-
After EXTENSIVE research on this topic, I purchased a Creative Labs Jukebox III. This constitutes my 4th generation of recording devices. I'll enumerate them, to demonstrate my fetish history (omitting dates, to protect the innocent) -
1) fostex 4 track cassette recorder
2) sony pro cassette recorder
3) sony DAT-man
4) Creative Labs Jukebox III (henceforth CLJB3)
My current requirements:
Well, it's a digital age that we live in - I wanted to be able to record (1)lots of (2)high-quality sound digitally, then (3)easily be able to move those tracks over to a PC - to tweak them, render to MP3s, put on the web, put on CDs, whatever, right?
I also wanted a device that (4)didn't frequently break and require expensive servicing - which is why I retired my broken option #3. Anybody wanna buy a used DAT-man? Cheap...
Those 4 simple requirements led me to my choice.
I considered the minidisk recorders, but those violate requirements 2 and 3. My CLJB3 records uncompressed .WAV files! (at a higher quality than my DAT player did) and offers USB and Firewire connectivity to my PC for FAST transfers.
I also considered memory card based devices, but this violated my requirement #1. What if I want to record a whole gig? What if it lasted 3 hours? Not unheard of, for my band.
That is 180 minutes x 10 megs/stereo minute - almost 2 gigs.
You don't want to know how much you have to pay for that much card-based memory. My CLJB3 sports 20 gigs of hard disk based memory. I can go to Europe on tour for 10 days and bring it all back with me! The latest versions hold 40 gigs. I am convinced that HD-based recording is THE WAY to go, at least for my requirements.
Don't forget about battery life when considering these things. My CLJB3 has 2 bays for Li-Ion batteries, and will run for 22 hours solid. Amazing...
The other thing I love about my CLJB3 - it is an MP3 player. Didn't think I needed one of those, but I sure do use it a lot. I listen to a lot more music than I used to, which is a VERY good thing... I have about 150 of my favorite albums on it, with PLENTY of room to record to my heart's content. If you care, you can also use it to store files.
If you aren't sold yet - go check out the specs on this bugger:
http://us.creative.com/products/product ... roduct=296
Two final suggestions on this topic-
1) get a good microphone - I love my AudioTechnica AT-822
2) get a good set of headphones - I love my Sony Pro cans.
Good luck!
jg