The bulk of the musical talk
Moderator: Uber Moderators
10 posts • Page 1 of 1
The internet offers a wealth of information, but as everyone here knows, it's hard to sift through all that information when it comes to researching tubas. I recently purchased a Getzen CB (Canadian Brass) 50 model CC tuba. It sounds beautiful, and I've heard that it is one of the best quintet horns a person can buy. I heard that it was originally designed from a cut horn. I was wondering if anyone on here knows anything else about it. I like to know the history behind my tubas. Thanks!
Cerveny CCB 601
Sherman Tenor Orenophone
The bell and bottom bow - yes on York. The top bow tapers a lot more slowly into a loop that is a lot longer, as you would imagine, for a CC. I have had my Monster Eb and a CB-50 side by side. The Rusk tuba's top bow *might* have been taken from a King.
However, the details of the valve set look a lot more like my Olds O-98 (not the O-99) than that of a King set. The ports are identical. The King ports are not the same. This is not insignificant. While the top bow is much different (again, possibly from a King BBb) the piston set could be a direct replacement for my homebuilt Eb tuba, which uses an Olds O-98 valve set.
The inner branches also might have come from a King. But I have not seen a King and a CB-50 side by side. (That is why I am not sure about the top bow.)
So I see parts from at least three tubas used in the horn that eventually became the CB-50. That does not include the rotary valve, which might have come from a smaller Miraphone horn. And the CB-50/G-50 tubas do, indeed, play quite well.
Wade, I thought the same, but Lee Stofer stopped by my place a few weeks ago. As you may know he bought up the remaining parts/tools from Getzen for the CB/GB-50 and will be building his own horns. He said he plans on having two at the Army Conference. We got to talking about his new venture/plans and I asked him if he had gotten a lot valve sets and he said yes. I then asked who they were made by and he believed they were of German origin. Which isn't too surprising I guess since a lot of the parts for the CB/GB-50 were sourced through MW and they had a longstanding interaction with Getzen.
No, I meant the one those were modeled after. It is a dead-on duplicate of the Olds design, also used on the Reynolds TU-22. It has some distinctive things that I have seen nowhere else but the CB-50. I was not referring to the source of the valves for the production horn. Sorry.
Here's a relevant thread from old tubenet:
http://www.chisham.com/tips/bbs/jan2002 ... 81154.html
Brief information in a Bub Rusk interview:
I had heard that the G50 was a copy of an instrument which Bob Rusk had made, not a copy of an instrument that Chuck Daellenbach had necessarily commissioned. I thought that the 3/4ish York cut was something that Bob Rusk somewhat regularly did and that Mister Chuck got one. I'm not certain that all of this is true, it's just what I heard. I also thought that the instruments that Mr Rusk made were built from the bugle and bell of York model 400 (??) BBb tubas (which share the same bell as a York Monster EEb and are pretty much the same size) like these:
(the pictures are from Dale Hale's site http://best-intown.com/CoolTubas/CoolTubas.htm)
That's not the "original." The so-called original was satin silver and made almost entirely of vintage parts, mostly York. At one time it was owned by a poster that was active on Tubenet. I seem to recall that the tuba was in the Pacific NW, but it's been years.
The one on the Noel album is one of the 4-valve CC tubas that Daellenbach had done for him when the CB-50 was just being rolled out. He has owned several variations of it, most with 4 valves, but some with and without carbon fiber bells, etc. George McCracken made those bells, by the way.
To this day Chuck Daellenbach is a huge fan of all things York. I've talked to him several times about the CB-50 tuba and he has always described it as "the tuba York could have built but never actually did" as York manufactured all of the parts needed, just never assembled them in that combination. The .689 bore is also what Daellenbach feels is the magic number for the valve set.
I don't know if the "original" existed and THEN Chuck saw it or if he actually commissioned Rusk to built it for him, but either way, that's essentially how the horn came to be. As others have mentioned it's a combination of vintage American tuba parts, mainly York Eb parts.
The production horns were produced, almost entirely, by Meinl Weston. They supposedly still have the bell mandrel in their inventory, too. Production valvesets were sourced through MW, but I don't know if they actually manufactured them.
And yes, Lee Stofer has the tooling to build these horns now. Likely with improvements.
Alexander 163 CC
Meinl Weston 45 SLP
10 posts • Page 1 of 1
Who is online