Page 1 of 2
high school horns?
Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 4:12 am
by mammagamma
hi all
a high-school-band-director friend/teacher of mine is looking into buy some new tubas for his students... and I was wondering what TubeNet's opinions were on the best options? In addition to looking at student models, he's looking for 4 valve piston tubas that are built like tanks and will last a long time for his future students to play on. He's got 2 yamaha 321 BBbs and a pretty decent King 2341 BBb.
Should he just go for more of the yamahas? They are definitely really sturdy but they play only okay. I suggested maybe getting some offbrand stuff like the jinbaos/tuba exchange tubas but we're not sure if they will last long enough without having to repair them to hell. Not sure of budget but thinking of buying 2-5 depending on price.
Thanks! (and sorry if this is in another thread, my search didnt find any matches)
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 9:26 am
by Musical_Eagle
If he has the budget for it, I'd highly recommend the King 2341's. Excellent intonation and sound with the only downside being that the new ones are soft and rather easy to dent. But if taken with proper care, they will last a long time. As for instruments built like tanks, I'm not too sure to be honest. Maybe some older detachable bell king 2341 but I don't know how often those come up for sale.
Hope this helps some.
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 11:31 am
by tyrell1111
I had St. Petersburg 202Ns throughout my high school career. I have absolutely no complaints about them! Easy maintenance and a fairly low price too. The worst part was making sure they looked nice for concerts because the silver plating got really fingerprint-y, but you can get them in a lacquer finish too. Other than the polishing, they were solid horns!

Re: high school horns?
Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 2:59 pm
by Dan Schultz
tyrell1111 wrote:I had St. Petersburg 202Ns throughout my high school career. I have absolutely no complaints about them! Easy maintenance and a fairly low price too. The worst part was making sure they looked nice for concerts because the silver plating got really fingerprint-y, but you can get them in a lacquer finish too. Other than the polishing, they were solid horns!

That wasn't silver. Those horns are nickel plated and tend to darken to a flat grey finish when exposed to some body chemistries. Silver polish won't work. You have to be very aggressive with a buffer and chrome polish (like is used on auto and truck bumpers).
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 3:09 pm
by tyrell1111
TubaTinker wrote:tyrell1111 wrote:I had St. Petersburg 202Ns throughout my high school career. I have absolutely no complaints about them! Easy maintenance and a fairly low price too. The worst part was making sure they looked nice for concerts because the silver plating got really fingerprint-y, but you can get them in a lacquer finish too. Other than the polishing, they were solid horns!

That wasn't silver. Those horns are nickel plated and tend to darken to a flat grey finish when exposed to some body chemistries. Silver polish won't work. You have to be very aggressive with a buffer and chrome polish (like is used on auto and truck bumpers).
Good to know! I guess I assumed that it was silver because I used Wright's Silver Cream and it cleaned up fairly nicely. I wouldn't mind playing one again, but I'd go for my Miraphone over those any day.
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 4:47 pm
by bisontuba
bloke wrote:King...no-brainer.
If not the budget for either King or Yamaha, the Eastman knock-off of the King.
+1
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2015 10:06 am
by iiipopes
bloke wrote:King...no-brainer.
If not the budget for either King or Yamaha, the Eastman knock-off of the King.
+2.
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2015 11:23 pm
by Art Hovey
The King is good, but I think the 4/4 BigMouthBrass is better. None of them are built like tanks. Kids will destroy any tuba if you allow them to. Part of your job is to teach them how to treat a tuba gently and store it safely.
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Sat Oct 10, 2015 12:01 am
by eupho
Check out the MACK BRASS 210 BBb tuba. Great tone and timbre.
Goto their website mackbrass.com or on youtube and listen the demo by Tom McGrady.
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Sat Oct 10, 2015 6:02 pm
by jmerring
I have had Yamaha 641, 321 and Chinese knock - offs of Miraphone 191 and 186. The Chinese were built like a tank and weighed as much. The weight was such, that I could never recommend one for a student (band owned). The rotary problem is, that they are very vulnerable to damage (by a young player). That is just an opinion; please take it as such. The school would be well served by Yamaha 321's. That is, if they have the funds; Yamaha horns are (IMHO) very expensive. They are worth the money. If you don't have major funds, I have to violate my stance concerning the Chinese horns. Mack Brass has very, very good Jin Bao tubas, that are thoroughly tested and inspected, at very good prices. Tom (at Mack) is a patient and honest man. The students must be very careful, so that the rotary valves (any make) don't get damaged.
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2015 8:40 am
by bisontuba
IMHO, to this day, I still do not understand why piston valve instruments aimed at the school market for front action pistons horns do not have a bar--just like the 4th piston on compensating euphoniums--to swing over to depress all 3 or 4 pistons for protection while not in use. It would save schools a lot of money in repair cost and repair techs a lot less horrors to fix.
Mark
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2015 11:48 am
by Mark
bisontuba wrote:IMHO, to this day, I still do not understand why piston valve instruments aimed at the school market for front action pistons horns do not have a bar--just like the 4th piston on compensating euphoniums--to swing over to depress all 3 or 4 pistons for protection while not in use. It would save schools a lot of money in repair cost and repair techs a lot less horrors to fix.
Do you really think most students would actually engage this protection?
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2015 12:32 pm
by bisontuba
Mark wrote:bisontuba wrote:IMHO, to this day, I still do not understand why piston valve instruments aimed at the school market for front action pistons horns do not have a bar--just like the 4th piston on compensating euphoniums--to swing over to depress all 3 or 4 pistons for protection while not in use. It would save schools a lot of money in repair cost and repair techs a lot less horrors to fix.
Do you really think most students would actually engage this protection?
Yes, if they were told close the pistons down after rehearsal or it can affect your grade in band....
BTW, I would have said Miraphone 186 BBb tubas for schools but having seen so many at repairman' shops just trashed, by kids, and the garland hanging by a thread, these days I would have to say no...
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2015 2:03 pm
by bisontuba
A lot of problems reflect on our Society's 'Me, me, me' attitude instead of what is the best for the collective good.
Are there any schools that have band kid's parents sign statements of liability on school instruments ( if legal

)....
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2015 2:29 pm
by bisontuba
I agree that a lot of kids just trash things that don't belong to them....it is a sorry state today.
However, even though I am not a fan of increased taxes, I ALWAYS vote Yes to pass the school budget....I feel that if I had a chance at things in school, others should too. And a better school makes for a better area to live, which should make home values continue to rise

Re: high school horns?
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2015 3:53 pm
by bisontuba
russiantuba wrote:We had a bunch of Miraphone 186 models when I was in middle school and high school....some had been around since the 1970s. Why was this so?
Each year, we had to get parents to sign a contract, I can't remember if that was the form we had to get notarized, stating that the student and parents were responsible for the horn, including damages that are beyond normal wear. There was only one tuba that was badly damaged at the middle school and that was when I was in high school, and the student had to pay. Some of the older sousaphones were falling apart and we ended up threatening to have to pay for the repairs, but the repair man backed up that it was normal wear. The contracts even stated that if repairs weren't done by the parent, they would be billed, effecting graduation.
My district was very strict about this to graduate. If we didn't turn in the horn, just like a book, we didn't graduate. It was that simple. We had a student not return a tuba that moved to another district, and the district recovered it and used the contract as a result.
What still baffles me is why other schools in other states won't do similar things. I think something that would decrease the growing entitlement of the youth these days is making them responsible for their actions, along with their parents. Severely bang up a horn, you pay. If you don't pay, you don't graduate.
+1
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2015 8:22 pm
by toobagrowl
Back when I was in high school in the 1990s, our band director was one of the last "old school" band directors. He would get up in your face and yell at you if you didn't listen or if you f-ed something up. He also taught us (well, the ones who cared/ listened

) to respect our instruments and take care of them. One day at afterschool band camp, one of the sousa players was tired and bitching about it and took off his sousa and layed it down hard on the ground. The band director yelled at him for doing so, and told him "that is a five-thousand-dollar-sousaphone" (now a $7,000+ sousa; a King 2350s).
I always took care of whatever King sousa I was playing because I knew they cost a lot, and that they were great sousas. We used our assortment of silver King BBb sousas for outdoor/marching AND indoor/concert playing
If you really need concert tubas for h.s., then King 2341.
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 9:03 am
by bisontuba
Curmudgeon wrote:6 weeks into the school year, I have several instruments in line right now from a "poor" school. The underprivileged youths at the school beat the backs of the valve casing with mouthpieces as to not have to play in band so they could goof around instead. The first tuba was no longer worth repairing as there is so much damage. That one tuba would consume more than the school's small entire yearly repair budget. It will salvaged out to be used for parts.
I'm sure their overwhelmed band teacher's threat of "lowered grades" will worry these darlings.
Getting reimbursement from the absentee parents will, I'm sure, be swift.
Times have changed...sigh..
PS -It does remind me of doing quintet school shows where if you are in wealthy suburban district at Q/A time, a question might be: ' Is your trumpet a Bach Strad?' -whereas in an inner city school at Q/A times, a question might be: 'How much does your horn cost?'
Different times.....
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 12:50 pm
by bisontuba
bloke wrote:bisontuba wrote:Times have changed...sigh..

yes...but you consider this "good" whereas I consider it "bad", and you deny that this (
https://www.google.com/search?q=LBJ+great+society ) is one of the primary causes, where as you will point to it as one of the primary solutions.
I won't say more specifically about that, but it should be obvious to all (who have a perspective that reaches back prior to the beginning of all of that) that ever since these programs were put in place (hour-after-hour/day-after-day/week-after-week/year-after-year/decade-after-decade) society has greatly deteriorated, and only those in the very top of government (as government has expanded in scope and size many-fold), and those at the very top of the private sector have benefited. Nearly everyone else has suffered, and there can no longer be any such thing (particularly in population-dense areas) of telling one's children to "go outside and play".
Most people here know the very nice and capable tuba professor at the U of Memphis. Yesterday, a Memphis cop was killed in a very "nice-looking" subdivision not far at all from his home. This sort of Sh!t simply did not happen prior to [what is linked to, above], which - imho - was intentionally put in place (along with many other things that have been put in place) to create chaos...and we now certainly have chaos.
bloke "have a teaching certificate, have never used it, will never use it, and pray every day for those who use theirs"
Happy Indigenous People's Day!
Re: high school horns?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 2:08 pm
by Donn
Here we go again. For those who subscribe to the societal-collapse religion, it's time to start work on the rubber tuba, to keep band programs going that would otherwise have to give up on brass tubas.