TubeNet

Hello!

I'm planning to buy a tuba in the next 2-3 years in around the 2k range. I want either a 4/4 BBb or CC and if the time comes, a 5/4 or 6/4 used. There are two major brands right now that are catching my attention.

The Schiller 4/4 BBb tuba : https://reverb.com/item/7077055-schille ... _BwE&pla=1" target="_blank

And the Mack brass tubas in general.(keeping an eye on that 4/4 CC)

Please let me know which one is better.
Also, which tuba is better chinese-made? BBb or CC?

Thanks!
-Raghul

let me rephrase the BBb CC question.

Which tuba type is better made in china? CC or BBb?

I can't really say that a key of tuba is better made in China than another... some models hold a better reputation, but that is independent of key. That schiller is a model that many have been happy with (same as the Mack 210) and the 410/miraclone is a great horn.

The biggest difference when buying a Chinese horn is who you buy it from, not the key or model... I have had great experiences with Wessex and with Mack brass (never purchased from Mack personally, but have spoken to Tom on multiple occasions and have sent many people and students his way). Tom is a tuba player, checks and fixes things when they come in, and has amazing customer service. Honestly, I would personally buy his version of that schiller, even though it would cost another $100) as he will help you out whenever you have an issue and not just during the first week or so. Plus, he has the best return policy out there. Plus, if Tom sells it, then it is going to be a good model from China. Wessex also has reliable models, as does John Packer and anything Baltimore Brass, Dillon Music, or the Horn Guys bring in. All six of those are people of trust.

My opinion, and YMMV, but I also recommend people look at who they are buying from when dealing with Chinese horns, and not the key or necessarily model.

Mark Finley wrote:....Depends on your future plans

Two years from now...

One of my friends at the university of Louisville recently purchased a Miraphone 186 copy from Mack brass, and he has absolutely no complaints. I've played on it a few times and it has great response, but personally I think it is a little hard to make the horn speak at a fortissimo like a real miraphone does, but for the price, it's hard to beat.

My opinion -- wait for 2 or 3 years, and then check the temperature again. Chinese tuba development can move at a fast pace, and 2 or 3 years makes a lot of difference (as compared to something like a Miraphone 186, which is just not going to change in the next 2 or 3 years).

For example, Wessex is constantly making improvements and announcing new changes and new models, at a very fast pace. Compare their "186-style tuba" of today to one from a few years ago. I understand that the valve linkages are more solid now, the z-valves are used, etc. I'm not saying that the older models are "bad," but if you keep being told that the new ones are "better" or have fixed previous issues... why would I want to buy or try an older one? Or rather, if you want to know what a Chinese tuba is like 2 or 3 years from now... you'll have to wait and ask about that 2 or 3 years from now.

Also, if you're looking at 2 or 3 years, start a savings plan to put aside some money and work towards that goal. If you can set aside $20 per week, every week, for 2 years, then you will have over $2,000 just like that. If saving towards a tuba is a priority, then this should be fairly easy and rewarding to see your "tuba fund" grow like this. Just put the money in the bank, not in your sock drawer!

So far, I have decided to get the MACK brass tuba.

Now, my school rents me a BBb tuba every year, so getting another one is pointless. However, AFTER HS, I might join a orchestra or a college band. For that, is 4/4 CC tuba or a BBb tuba better?

Thanks!
-Raghul

What tuba should I get if I'm double-majoring?

(yes I have big goals in life)

Thanks!
-Raghul

I got this guys. Wait and see what your teacher in college suggest. They will help you find what you need.

Voisi1ev wrote:I got this guys. Wait and see what your teacher in college suggest. They will help you find what you need.

This. At your age/skill level, this kind of purchase is best undertaken with professional advice.

Maybe a chinese Moog instead?

Right now, Bell high school and Central have 4/4 BBb miraphones.

Call me inpatient, but I don't know yet if I am doing a double major. If the opportunity, finances, and workload work out, I will definitely do it. Right now i'm in 9th, so in 2-3 years, i'll be close college anyway. I just want a broad idea if prof. want CC or BBb tubas in college.

Thanks!
-Raghul

If you keep your eyes open and save your money... you can buy a good used name brand tuba.

I currently have three refurbished B & S/VMI BBb rotary tubas here within your budget that will run circles around the Chinese horns you mentioned.

If you want to go to college for music, then ask college professors what their advice is regarding buying a tuba. I have never personally seen a studio professor recommend a BBb tuba, usually only CC. During my undergrad, which was a very high quality competitive program, a student coming in with a Chinese horn would generally get rid of it and buy a German horn within their first year. I'm not saying that there are not any genuinely good Chinese tubas out there, but ordering a brand new mack brass horn from china sounds like a fast track to receiving a ruined tuba. If you intend to take tuba playing seriously as a career choice, then consider a high quality used horn. I know many people that have bought old Miraphone 186s for at or less than $3,000. I also bought my 181 F tuba for not too much over that price. If your high school lends tubas, then keep playing on those horns until your budget raises up to that of a quality horn.

Dan Schultz wrote:If you keep your eyes open and save your money... you can buy a good used name brand tuba.

I currently have three refurbished B & S/VMI BBb rotary tubas here within your budget that will run circles around the Chinese horns you mentioned.

THIS! The VMI BBb is a great tuba, far better than any Chinese made tuba I've ever put my hands on.
I'm glad I have my tuba, but if I could trade right now for one of those, I would.