"amateur"/"professional" - skills not often discussed (here)

The bulk of the musical talk
rocksanddirt
4 valves
4 valves
Posts: 551
Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2008 10:14 pm

Re: "amateur"/"professional" - skills not often discussed (h

Post by rocksanddirt »

quick random observation. I've been in some groups that spend a lot of time on tuning, and it doesn't really help as the members think of it like calibration. Once done it's correct until you turn the machine off.

Music is a form of communication and therefore takes listening and blending and all those lovely traits bloke listed up front to really have an ensemble bring the music.
User avatar
Alex C
pro musician
pro musician
Posts: 2225
Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 10:34 am
Location: Cybertexas

Re: "amateur"/"professional" - skills not often discussed (h

Post by Alex C »

To me, a professional musician can be identified by 1) showing up ahead of time, 2) present and ready to play at the requested time, 3) able to play the part as indicated on the page, 4) does not need a rehearsal to "get it down," 5) is not a distraction or a drama queen, 6) is able to greet and then bid a friendly farewell at the end of the gig.

It is surprising how many time 2-3 and 4 just don't happen. Anybody can have a bad night with one or more of these but if you see someone over and over struggling to fit a technical pattern into a measure, that's an amateur.

The gig leader has a different set of parameters.
City Intonation Inspector - Dallas Texas
"Holding the Bordognian Fabric of the Universe together through better pitch, one note at a time."

Practicing results in increased atmospheric CO2 thus causing global warming.
User avatar
jperry1466
bugler
bugler
Posts: 167
Joined: Fri Dec 01, 2017 12:29 am
Location: North Central Texas

Re: "amateur"/"professional" - skills not often discussed (h

Post by jperry1466 »

bloke wrote:...frankness communicates more clearly than euphemisms/apologetic adjectives/Newspeak/pc-speak/beating-around-the-bush, and more human beings (at least many Americans - once again, in my estimation) need to grow a reasonably thick skin and address issues, rather than defending issues.
i.e.
"bloke, Your entrance is late and your pitch is flat."
~vs.~
"bloke, I'm not immediately hearing your sound in the corporate sound, and it also doesn't seem to be resonating."
...and bloke (simply) fixing it, and not taking offense.
Agreed. Criticism is just that - critical assistance and not personal attack. And besides, it takes me a lot longer to figure out what said pc-speak person just said and meant than someone saying, "hey, you're flat and coming in late". I don't mind fixing a problem that I caused and sure don't get offended by it being pointed out to me.
User avatar
Leland
pro musician
pro musician
Posts: 1649
Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 11:54 am
Location: Washington, DC

Re: "amateur"/"professional" - skills not often discussed (h

Post by Leland »

bloke wrote: i.e.
"bloke, Your entrance is late and your pitch is flat."
~vs.~
"bloke, I'm not immediately hearing your sound in the corporate sound, and it also doesn't seem to be resonating."

...and bloke (simply) fixing it, and not taking offense.
+1.

I had a chance to play a hornline rehearsal under Robert W. Smith, and he was excellent at dissecting what we just played, describing how it was incorrect, and what to do to fix it. He used zero personal attacks (like, "you must not be thinking about [blah blah]", etc) and made no comments about who we were or what our motivations were. He focused only on the product. We made greater strides in six hours than some of my other groups could make in a month.
timothy42b
3 valves
3 valves
Posts: 466
Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 9:57 pm

Re: "amateur"/"professional" - skills not often discussed (h

Post by timothy42b »

Alex C wrote:To me, a professional musician can be identified by 1) showing up ahead of time, 2) present and ready to play at the requested time, 3) able to play the part as indicated on the page, 4) does not need a rehearsal to "get it down," 5) is not a distraction or a drama queen, 6) is able to greet and then bid a friendly farewell at the end of the gig.

It is surprising how many time 2-3 and 4 just don't happen. Anybody can have a bad night with one or more of these but if you see someone over and over struggling to fit a technical pattern into a measure, that's an amateur.

The gig leader has a different set of parameters.
7. (subset of 2)). Brings all the equipment necessary. I can not imagine why a professional musician (paid, not a volunteer) would show up for a dimly lit church service and not bother to bring a stand light. Okay, once, but repeatedly? I've loaned mine many times, but shake my head every time. If a harpist has been hired, I don't even think twice, I throw an extra stand light in the bag for him/her.

8. (subset of 4) Sightreads instead of preparing. You had the music ahead of time, you're getting paid to play/sing/perform, and you don't do your homework. I've bit my tongue with paid soloists many a time, yesterday I slipped and said something. His reply, "I just show up and sing." Youngster, okay, but somewhere along the line a mentor should explain professionalism. We work on sightreading every day, but we never do it unnecessarily.

9. No Call, No Show, means I never hire you again and I call all my friends and pass the word. You have multiple phone numbers and email addresses, there's just no way you can't let me know.
timothy42b
3 valves
3 valves
Posts: 466
Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 9:57 pm

Re: "amateur"/"professional" - skills not often discussed (h

Post by timothy42b »

bloke wrote: poorly-lit venue-provided music stands: That's (first/foremost) a sign of the venue owner/manager being unprepared...or (again) - blurring word meanings - being "unprofessional".
I agree with everything else, but Celtic evening services are designed to be contemplative, dimly lit with lots of candles. If you regularly do music for these, you know what to expect. Some local harpists and flutists do a lot of these. And show up, and ask for a light. Arghh.

I screwed up myself yesterday. I'd played this Christmas gig last year, in a brightly lit cafeteria space. This year they moved it to a dark orchestra pit and I didn't have a standlight myself, felt like an idiot since I'm a bit, er, critical of showing up unprepared. I usually have it in the bag, plus a couple of wire stands for others who forget, but I was charging the batteries and forgot to grab it.

One community band I fill in with played concerts in a dimly lit barn used by the theater department. I bought a 250 watt builder's flood light at Home Depot and set it up behind our row. Tubas and trombones could see fine; clarinets across from them not so much.
dunelandmusic
bugler
bugler
Posts: 108
Joined: Thu Jul 29, 2004 12:16 am

Re: "amateur"/"professional" - skills not often discussed (h

Post by dunelandmusic »

With regards to find a place to play, I am friends with a guy who conducts band for home schoolers. They haven't had a tuba player in 10 years, so I get to play with them. No money, just joy. Just finished our two concerts for the holidays last night. Not very taxing, usually a cadet band, a symphonic band, and some orchestra pieces. Opportunities for ensemble play can be scarce. I'll keep playing what I'm offered.
Jeff
User avatar
BrassedOn
bugler
bugler
Posts: 115
Joined: Sun Aug 19, 2018 10:00 am
Location: Texas

Re: "amateur"/"professional" - skills not often discussed (h

Post by BrassedOn »

Ted Cox wrote:Author Steven Pressfield has written a couple of books regarding the differences between amateurs and professionals.....The BEST sentence in both books comes at the end of The Art of War. Pressfield writes: "resistance is the dragon that guards the gold." Each of us must fight our very own dragon each and every day in order to recover the gold hidden within each of us.
Then rather than ‘professional’, tag me as ‘dragon slayer’.
I wake each day with sword in hand.

I always thought it was easier to identify an amateur, even when ‘twas me.
"Do less, better."
19xx? Blessing Sousaphone BBb
1970s King 3b Silver Sonic
1976 Fender Precision bass
Post Reply