
Anyhow, the fireplace is a pre-fab unit and leaks cold air in like a sieve. The glass doors don't do much but remind you that the unit is 20 years old. I pulled the doors a while back, and IMO it looks better. It also allows me to do this (sorry for P&S quality pics):

Here is the back and how it works. There is some fairly thick weather stripping to seal the edges and magnets to hold it in place. The cross brace is needed to keep it flat. It is 3/16 oak plywood with oak 1x2 framing. Minimal tools (jigsaw, circular saw, drill) were required. All fastening is done with #6 x 1" wood screws. Please note: When using oak, always pre-drill the holes. Even with pre-drilling, I stopped short a few times and my drill twisted the head off of a few screws.

For the summer (where all of this started) I have a portable A/C unit that goes in my living room. All of my windows downstairs are Anderson crank out windows, so there is no suitable place for the A/C exhaust. Voila!

The room is far less drafty when this is in place and the cycle time for the heat seems to be longer. Even when the flue is closed, there was a significant draft on cold (lower than 20 degrees F) days. I'm probably out around $75 for supplies, but I went with oak so that I can stain it and match the existing woodwork and floors.
I hope a few of you find this useful. I don't use the fireplace much, but even if I need/want to use it, the magnets (which are held on with Super Glue) allow for this to pop on and off in seconds, while maintaining a decent seal.