-Rudolf Meinl RM1C45 CC Tuba
-Meinl Weston 45S-LP F tuba
-Miraphone 12915VC CC Tuba
-Yamaha YCB-621S CC
Can anyone tell me the pros and cons of these tubas?
Forum rules
This forum is for buying or selling your personal equipment. Sponsored selling is allowed as well. All ads are required to have the following information: Price (even for trades), brand, model, and location (City and State, for instruments, not accessories). It is acceptable to link to an external ad if you are promoting a sale of your personal equipment. No Ebay auctions, but "Buy It Now" listings are fine. Photos are HIGHLY suggested as well, and may be hosted on Google Drive, or elsewhere. If you see an ad that does not meet these criteria, please report it.
This forum is for buying or selling your personal equipment. Sponsored selling is allowed as well. All ads are required to have the following information: Price (even for trades), brand, model, and location (City and State, for instruments, not accessories). It is acceptable to link to an external ad if you are promoting a sale of your personal equipment. No Ebay auctions, but "Buy It Now" listings are fine. Photos are HIGHLY suggested as well, and may be hosted on Google Drive, or elsewhere. If you see an ad that does not meet these criteria, please report it.
-
tuba114
- bugler
- Posts: 132
- Joined: Wed Sep 14, 2005 8:35 pm
- Location: Texas
- Contact:
-
octavelower
- bugler
- Posts: 75
- Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 12:56 am
- Location: Columbus, OH
- Contact:
I agree
I had a 5/4 Rudy as well, loved the sound. If I were to buy a Rudy again, I would get the 4/4 (really a 5/4). All the Rudy's have a great sound but the 5/4 is just SO big! Really only useful in large ensemble.
If I bought the Meinl F tuba, I would get the piston one. Just personal preference, I don't like rotors very much. (Main reason I sold my Rudy)
For F tubas of that size, I would also look at the Wilson and the Yamaha and maybe the Gronitz though it is the smallest of the tubas on this list and though the low range is quite good on it, it doesn't quite get the same type of sound down there as the others do.
I now own a Miraphone 1291 CC and LOVE it. I would put it against ANY other comparable sized CC out there, even the mighty Hirsbrunners.
The Yamaha 621 CC is pretty much obsolete at this point. It is not versatile at all, you can basically use it for solo and quintet work. But why would you when ANY of the F tubas above would do a better job and be more useful?
Just some of my thoughts on the subject.
Corey
If I bought the Meinl F tuba, I would get the piston one. Just personal preference, I don't like rotors very much. (Main reason I sold my Rudy)
For F tubas of that size, I would also look at the Wilson and the Yamaha and maybe the Gronitz though it is the smallest of the tubas on this list and though the low range is quite good on it, it doesn't quite get the same type of sound down there as the others do.
I now own a Miraphone 1291 CC and LOVE it. I would put it against ANY other comparable sized CC out there, even the mighty Hirsbrunners.
The Yamaha 621 CC is pretty much obsolete at this point. It is not versatile at all, you can basically use it for solo and quintet work. But why would you when ANY of the F tubas above would do a better job and be more useful?
Just some of my thoughts on the subject.
Corey
-
MartyNeilan
- 6 valves
- Posts: 4876
- Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 3:06 am
- Location: Practicing counting rests.