Dean wrote:Colleges and universities don't have a "responsibility" to "make" job-winners. They only have to provide the tools so those students are able to succeed. Whether the student succeeds is up to them and them alone.
I would go even further, and say that colleges
should not be concerned about job training in their undergraduate degrees. They should be concerned about education. A broadly educated person should know a lot about a lot of subjects, and that broad knowledge can provide the basis for making a decent living doing something or other.
Lots of people study languages, or mathematics, or history, or even science and end up in a completely different field. But they succeed because in addition to language, history, or science, they also learned language, mathematics, history, AND science.
A master's degree is another matter. That's a job-training degree.
You learn how to do a job by being trained by one who is a master at doing that job. That's just as true for engineers as it is for musicians.
90% of the engineering calculations I used in daily work I learned post-grad. But that 90% would not have been possible without the 10% I learned in school. And much of what makes me a competent engineer is the non-engineering stuff or engineering stuff in other fields that I learned. I have no use for engineers who can only calculate.
Any undergraduate degree in music performance should include wide-ranging topics in languages, mathematics, history, and science, sufficient to provide a well-rounded education. If it does, and if the student takes that breadth seriously, they'll come out of it with far more than major and minor scales. Most of what they learn in terms of music performance they'll get in their studio and lessons, and those can be had outside college. In fact, if performing professionally was my goal, I might choose a university near a city where there is a really high-end professional who could teach me, and then get a good general education at college while studying and practicing my butt off with the pro. Whether the pro is on the faculty or not almost doesn't matter.
Someone close to me has a recent undergraduate degree in music performance, and is working on a master's in performance. It's unlikely that a pro career is in the cards, but the kid has learned to be self-sufficient and that's what counts. I am surely not worried about the kid being successful in life.
Rick "not confusing trade schools with universities" Denney