What is a real 5/4 tuba?
- Watchman
- bugler
- Posts: 139
- Joined: Mon Mar 02, 2009 9:32 pm
What is a real 5/4 tuba?
In my mind categorizing sizes of tuba goes like this:
3/4 - beginning band "baby" tuba
4/4 - bigger than 3/4 but not too big.
6/4 - CSO York
5/4 - ????
The 5/4 designation seems rather problematic. Miraphone makes a bunch of 5/4 piston tubas that seem to me like 4/4 tubas. Rudy Meinl has a 5/4 that is huge. B&S PT-6 or a Thor is a "real" 5/4 to me, but a lot bigger than a Meinl 2000 which some people call 5/4. Also, what are the Miraphone 187, 188, 190? Beefed up 4/4? Isn't that the definition of 5/4? People don't call them 5/4 though. What about an HB-21? Everybody seems to agree that's a 4/4, but it feels bigger to me than a Miraphone 129X.
Anyway. What do you all think a 5/4 tuba is?
3/4 - beginning band "baby" tuba
4/4 - bigger than 3/4 but not too big.
6/4 - CSO York
5/4 - ????
The 5/4 designation seems rather problematic. Miraphone makes a bunch of 5/4 piston tubas that seem to me like 4/4 tubas. Rudy Meinl has a 5/4 that is huge. B&S PT-6 or a Thor is a "real" 5/4 to me, but a lot bigger than a Meinl 2000 which some people call 5/4. Also, what are the Miraphone 187, 188, 190? Beefed up 4/4? Isn't that the definition of 5/4? People don't call them 5/4 though. What about an HB-21? Everybody seems to agree that's a 4/4, but it feels bigger to me than a Miraphone 129X.
Anyway. What do you all think a 5/4 tuba is?
- tylerferris1213
- 3 valves
- Posts: 487
- Joined: Tue Sep 25, 2012 9:53 pm
- Location: NW Ohio
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
I think of it as a horn with ALMOST the control of a 4/4, but ALMOST the same sound as a 6/4. If you can't have a 4/4 AND a 6/4, get a 5/4. I also know a lot of people use 5/4's for auditions.
Tyler Ferris
Wessex British F
York Monster Eb
Getzen CB-50 CC
Cerveny CBB-601 BBb
"Yamayork" Frankentuba Contrabass FF
Wessex British F
York Monster Eb
Getzen CB-50 CC
Cerveny CBB-601 BBb
"Yamayork" Frankentuba Contrabass FF
- Ken Crawford
- 4 valves
- Posts: 722
- Joined: Sat Jun 23, 2012 10:45 am
- Location: Rexburg, ID
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
A 5/4 tuba has a bell throat that measures between 17-18.5 inches in circumference at the ferrule. That's the official rule.
6/4 18.5+
4/4 less than 17"
3/4 really small...
These are the official, unquestionable rules for ?/4 tuba sizes.
6/4 18.5+
4/4 less than 17"
3/4 really small...
These are the official, unquestionable rules for ?/4 tuba sizes.
- WakinAZ
- Community Band Button-Masher
- Posts: 1083
- Joined: Sat Sep 02, 2006 4:03 pm
- Location: Back Row
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
I think a 5/4 tuba is bigger than a 4/4 tuba, but smaller than a 6/4.
It's kind of like pornography - you know it when you see it.
But (as it has been noted on this site), the sizing seems to be creeping up.
A horn that was considered the standard 4/4 back in the day looks kind of wimpy these days.
[North Americans and most Europeans are getting bigger/fatter, discuss..]
188s and 187s, etc. might be 9/8 or 4/4+. Bringing in */8 designations in might be helpful, but a lot of tuba players cannot count past 4.
Eric "currently seeking a 5/4 BBb rotary" L.
It's kind of like pornography - you know it when you see it.
But (as it has been noted on this site), the sizing seems to be creeping up.
A horn that was considered the standard 4/4 back in the day looks kind of wimpy these days.
[North Americans and most Europeans are getting bigger/fatter, discuss..]
188s and 187s, etc. might be 9/8 or 4/4+. Bringing in */8 designations in might be helpful, but a lot of tuba players cannot count past 4.
Eric "currently seeking a 5/4 BBb rotary" L.
- roweenie
- pro musician
- Posts: 2165
- Joined: Mon Mar 05, 2007 10:17 am
- Location: Waiting on a vintage tow truck
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
With the valves missing, I'd say it looks more like 5/8ths to me....bloke wrote:not sure either, but this is about 3/4 tuba:What do you all think a 5/4 tuba is?
btw: The contraction for "you all" is "y'all".
"Even a broken clock is right twice a day".
-
- 4 valves
- Posts: 565
- Joined: Tue Mar 03, 2015 8:11 am
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
i will accept nothing short of PURE WATER DISPLACEMENT.
maybe with a small correction factor for valve type and #.
maybe with a small correction factor for valve type and #.
- swillafew
- 5 valves
- Posts: 1029
- Joined: Sun Nov 22, 2009 6:20 pm
- Location: Aurora, IL
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
5/4 on the left, 4/4 on the right, both B&S. They both play well, sound a little different but not different enough to correspond to the math of the fraction. 4/4 horn is supposed to be the same bell and bugle as a Thor which is 5/4.
MORE AIR
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
I have always thought of the PT6P as a prototypical 5/4 size tuba.
- Dylan King
- YouTube Tubist
- Posts: 1601
- Joined: Tue Aug 17, 2004 1:56 am
- Location: Weddington, NC, USA.
- Contact:
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
I think of it like t-shirt sizes.
3/4 = Medium
4/4 = Large
5/4 = XL
6/4 = XXL
There is no size “Small”.
We’re talking tubas, after all.
3/4 = Medium
4/4 = Large
5/4 = XL
6/4 = XXL
There is no size “Small”.
We’re talking tubas, after all.
Mira 291 CC
Yorkbrunner CC
Eastman CC
YFB-822 F
YFB-621 F
PT-10 F Clone
MackMini F
YBL622 B-TB
YSL891Z TB
Xeno Bb/C Trps
Taylor Bb/C Trp
Eclipse C Trp
Yamaha C Pic
Lawler C7 Trp
Osmun Corumpet
Carol Pocket Trp
Schagerl Gansch Horn
Monette Ajna Trumpet
Yorkbrunner CC
Eastman CC
YFB-822 F
YFB-621 F
PT-10 F Clone
MackMini F
YBL622 B-TB
YSL891Z TB
Xeno Bb/C Trps
Taylor Bb/C Trp
Eclipse C Trp
Yamaha C Pic
Lawler C7 Trp
Osmun Corumpet
Carol Pocket Trp
Schagerl Gansch Horn
Monette Ajna Trumpet
-
- 3 valves
- Posts: 276
- Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2015 4:42 pm
- Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
Dylan King wrote: 3/4 = Medium
4/4 = Large
5/4 = XL
6/4 = XXL
Yamaha YEB-321 Eb 4v TA tuba
Meinl-Weston 2141 Eb 5v FA tuba
Hirsbrunner Bb 3v TA compensated euph
Wessex Dolce Bb 3+1v TA compensated euph
Alto/tenor/bass trombones in various sizes/plugs
Meinl-Weston 2141 Eb 5v FA tuba
Hirsbrunner Bb 3v TA compensated euph
Wessex Dolce Bb 3+1v TA compensated euph
Alto/tenor/bass trombones in various sizes/plugs
-
- 3 valves
- Posts: 342
- Joined: Thu May 21, 2009 12:24 am
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
+1TheGoyWonder wrote:i will accept nothing short of PURE WATER DISPLACEMENT.
maybe with a small correction factor for valve type and #.
Using water, or beer, would be repeatable and precise.
- Ken Crawford
- 4 valves
- Posts: 722
- Joined: Sat Jun 23, 2012 10:45 am
- Location: Rexburg, ID
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
Well the GR55 they call a 5/4, an extra inch of bell flare and larger bore 4th valve.cktuba wrote:IMHO the GR51 is a 5/4 (look at the bell throat and bows) and one of (if not the) best contrabass tubas made by B&S. I have been seriously considering a switch to BBb... Because of how well they play and the fact that they are much more affordable than their CC cousins.
- swillafew
- 5 valves
- Posts: 1029
- Joined: Sun Nov 22, 2009 6:20 pm
- Location: Aurora, IL
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
In the spirit of agreement, I think the math on the fractions is not so important as the sound made.IMHO the GR51 is a 5/4 (look at the bell throat and bows) and one of (if not the) best contrabass tubas made by B&S. I have been seriously considering a switch to BBb... Because of how well they play and the fact that they are much more affordable than their CC cousins.
Those are nice horns, I played one the day I bought the 51. They are very close cousins, hard for me to tell that one was better or even different.Well the GR55 they call a 5/4, an extra inch of bell flare and larger bore 4th valve.
MORE AIR
- groth
- 3 valves
- Posts: 394
- Joined: Sat Jun 17, 2017 11:37 am
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
Anything over 40'' tall might be considered 5/4.
- Dan Schultz
- TubaTinker
- Posts: 10424
- Joined: Thu Mar 18, 2004 10:46 pm
- Location: Newburgh, Indiana
- Contact:
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
The B & S model 101 tubas with a stovepipe bell are 42" overall and would not qualify as a 5/4 in my estimation.groth wrote:Anything over 40'' tall might be considered 5/4.
Dan Schultz
"The Village Tinker"
http://www.thevillagetinker.com" target="_blank
Current 'stable'... Rudolf Meinl 5/4, Marzan (by Willson) euph, King 2341, Alphorn, and other strange stuff.
"The Village Tinker"
http://www.thevillagetinker.com" target="_blank
Current 'stable'... Rudolf Meinl 5/4, Marzan (by Willson) euph, King 2341, Alphorn, and other strange stuff.
-
- 3 valves
- Posts: 288
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 2:35 am
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
It's like asking what flavor of ice cream is best, or who had the best curveball ever. Tuba size classifications are about as clearly delineated as the morning fog.
For whatever reason, I think 5/4 marketed tubas to be kind of the "McMansions" of the tuba world. Not from a quality or sound perspective, just marketing. Not many horns trying to be 4/4 tubas or 6/4 tubas (6450 maybe), but the 5/4 designation is the classification dumping ground for anything bigger than a 186. Maybe it just seems that way to me. Don't get me wrong, lots of great tubas in there.
The prototypical 5/4 would seem to be PT6/PT6-P/5450/GR55. Lots of other tubas marketed as 5/4 feel up for grabs with regards to classification.
Probably wrong on lots of counts, and not above being corrected. Doesn't matter much anyhow.
For whatever reason, I think 5/4 marketed tubas to be kind of the "McMansions" of the tuba world. Not from a quality or sound perspective, just marketing. Not many horns trying to be 4/4 tubas or 6/4 tubas (6450 maybe), but the 5/4 designation is the classification dumping ground for anything bigger than a 186. Maybe it just seems that way to me. Don't get me wrong, lots of great tubas in there.
The prototypical 5/4 would seem to be PT6/PT6-P/5450/GR55. Lots of other tubas marketed as 5/4 feel up for grabs with regards to classification.
Probably wrong on lots of counts, and not above being corrected. Doesn't matter much anyhow.
-
- bugler
- Posts: 145
- Joined: Fri May 02, 2008 8:39 am
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
I'm curious where these "official and unquestionable" rules originated and if all tuba manufacturers agree with them.A 5/4 tuba has a bell throat that measures between 17-18.5 inches in circumference at the ferrule. That's the official rule.
6/4 18.5+
4/4 less than 17"
3/4 really small...
These are the official, unquestionable rules for ?/4 tuba sizes.
kmorgancraw
- Ken Crawford
- 4 valves
- Posts: 722
- Joined: Sat Jun 23, 2012 10:45 am
- Location: Rexburg, ID
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
On the internet....But really, bell girth is the determining factor in tuba ?/4 size. It isn't overall height, bore size or bell diameter.williamp wrote:I'm curious where these "official and unquestionable" rules originated and if all tuba manufacturers agree with them.A 5/4 tuba has a bell throat that measures between 17-18.5 inches in circumference at the ferrule. That's the official rule.
6/4 18.5+
4/4 less than 17"
3/4 really small...
These are the official, unquestionable rules for ?/4 tuba sizes.
kmorgancraw
If it were bore size, a Cerveny piggy would be "bigger" than the CSO York.
If it were bell diameter, a Conn 3J would be the same size as the CSO York.
If it were over height, a King pit tuba would be a 9/4 tuba.
Bell girth gives a tuba it's characteristic sound. For example, the BMB line. The 4/4 vs 6/4 tubas are identical aside from their bell girths, and of course matching outer bows.
A uniform place to take this measurement is at the ferrule mentioned previously.
There are companies that violate the official rules occasionally, like the GR51/55 example in which they tack on a tiny bit of bell diameter and 4th valve bore size and market two "different" tubas.
Disclaimer: There are no official rules.
Last edited by Ken Crawford on Mon Nov 13, 2017 8:32 am, edited 1 time in total.
- roweenie
- pro musician
- Posts: 2165
- Joined: Mon Mar 05, 2007 10:17 am
- Location: Waiting on a vintage tow truck
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
https://youtu.be/X-pHe879l60" target="_blank
"Even a broken clock is right twice a day".
-
- 4 valves
- Posts: 585
- Joined: Thu Jul 24, 2014 7:47 pm
Re: What is a real 5/4 tuba?
Where would something like the PCK sit? It's not nearly as large as some other 6/4's, but we'll bigger then a 186