Origins of the Great Divide

The bulk of the musical talk
obreitys
bugler
bugler
Posts: 34
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2017 10:04 pm

Origins of the Great Divide

Post by obreitys »

Just out of curiosity, would any of you gurus happen to know exactly *why* we have the big split between CC in North American orchestra and BBb in Europe? The recent re-interest in BBb in N. American orchestra got me wondering.

The fact that several people started cutting down BBb's to CC several decades ago would seem to prove that at one point, BBb's were pretty common in the orchestra scene here. What happened to turn the tide toward CC? Was there a trigger event of some kind, or was it an eventual conversion (because of change- of-taste in American orchestra repertoire perhaps)?
User avatar
Ken Crawford
4 valves
4 valves
Posts: 722
Joined: Sat Jun 23, 2012 10:45 am
Location: Rexburg, ID

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by Ken Crawford »

Rotary BBb in Germany/Europe because it always has been. Piston CC in America because Chicago York.

Let the postmortem equine beating begin!
obreitys
bugler
bugler
Posts: 34
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2017 10:04 pm

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by obreitys »

There shall be no postmortem equine beating! :wink:

This post was NOT meant to discuss the merits of BBb vs. CC in orchestra. Rather, I'm interested in when / how the widespread use of CC in American orchestra (and the associated dogma) came into being.

Ken, am I correct in assuming you're saying the CC-in- orchestra tradition started after the Chicago York came out? Wouldn't that mean that there was already a clear preference for CC at that point, resulting in production of that instrument? Or did everybody latch onto it after it was introduced because it was the first "true American" orchestral tuba?
toobagrowl
5 valves
5 valves
Posts: 1525
Joined: Mon Aug 02, 2010 3:12 pm
Location: USA

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by toobagrowl »

obreitys wrote: Rather, I'm interested in when / how the widespread use of CC in American orchestra (and the associated dogma) came into being.
Because of Bill Bell and Arnold Jacobs. They were both "orchestra tuba titans" who held a lot of sway in the tuba community. Bill Bell and his students on King 4/4 rotary CC tubas, as well as Alex, Meinl and Mirafone rotary CC tubas; Arnold Jacobs & students on 6/4 York-a-phone piston CC tubas.

Before Bell and Jacobs 'popularized' CC tuba in US orchestras, tuba pitch & type were far less 'standardized'. But even after the 'standardization' of CC tuba use in US orchestras, there were a few guys who still prefered BBb for their 'big tuba', such as the late Ev Gilmore (formerly, Dallas Symphony), James Jenkins (Jacksonville Symphony), Ross Tolbert (formerly, Minnesota Orchestra) and I'm sure a few others :!:
Bill B
bugler
bugler
Posts: 28
Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 10:24 am

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by Bill B »

bloke wrote:"orchester tuben"...??

' seems to me, either tuben in B and E or tuben in A and E would make the most sense.
I've always thought a tuba in "A" would make playing the "Ride of the Valkyries" really easy.
User avatar
GC
5 valves
5 valves
Posts: 1800
Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 5:52 am
Location: Rome, GA (between Rosedale and Armuchee)

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by GC »

Were Jacobs and Bell influenced by Helleburg's use of CC?
JP/Sterling 377 compensating Eb; Warburton "The Grail" T.G.4, RM-9 7.8, Yamaha 66D4; for sale > 1914 Conn Monster Eb (my avatar), ca. 1905 Fillmore Bros 1/4-size Eb, Bach 42B trombone
toobagrowl
5 valves
5 valves
Posts: 1525
Joined: Mon Aug 02, 2010 3:12 pm
Location: USA

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by toobagrowl »

the elephant wrote:August Helleberg.
^ Arguably the first to use CC tuba in a major US orchestra. But I'd argue the use of CC tubas didn't become popular/widespread in orchestras until Bell and Jacobs came into the scene. You still had guys like Kilton V. Smith using a Kruspe F tuba for everything in Boston until Chester Schmitz won that spot in the mid-1960s on an Alex 163 CC :idea: And after Helleburg and Geib, but before Bell in the NY Phil, Vincent Vanni used a large Cerveny F in the orchestra :idea:
obreitys
bugler
bugler
Posts: 34
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2017 10:04 pm

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by obreitys »

Wow. Lots of interesting information. Thanks to everyone who's contributed so far!
User avatar
T. J. Ricer
pro musician
pro musician
Posts: 441
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:17 pm
Contact:

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by T. J. Ricer »

Around the same time, weren’t there C melody saxophones and “Preacher” trombones in C for reading out of the hymnal? Maybe we were the only ones to see a benefit from what was a fad for everyone else?

Was Geib after Helleberg?

I seem to remember reading a story of Bill Bell getting a Cerveny CC before his Cincinnati audition and figuring out the fingerings right before the audition because “you play a CC in orchestra” and he had played BBb in the Sousa Band.
Thomas J. Ricer, DMA
Royal Hawaiian Band - University of Hawaii at Manoa - Yamaha Performing Artist

http://www.TJRicer.com

"Life is what happens to you while you're busy making other plans." -John Lennon
Three Valves
6 valves
6 valves
Posts: 4230
Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2015 9:44 am
Location: With my fellow Thought Criminals

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by Three Valves »

Twin cam I-6 vs V8.

Protestant vs Catholic.

N vs S.

E vs W.

Bring it!! :tuba:
I am committed to the advancement of civil rights, minus the Marxist intimidation and thuggery of BLM.
Heavy_Metal
5 valves
5 valves
Posts: 1713
Joined: Fri Jul 20, 2012 10:42 pm
Location: Baltimore, MD, USA

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by Heavy_Metal »

Three Valves wrote:Twin cam I-6 vs V8.

Protestant vs Catholic.

N vs S.

E vs W.

Bring it!! :tuba:
You forgot:

Kirk vs. Picard

Ginger vs. Mary Ann

Daphne vs. Velma
Principal tuba, Bel Air Community Band
Old (early 1900s?) Alexander BBb proto-163
1976 Sonora (B&S 101) 4-rotor BBb
1964 Conn 20J/21J BBb (one body, both bells)
1970s Marzan Slant-rotor BBb
~1904 York 3P BBb Helicon
Old Alex Comp.F, in shop
hup_d_dup
4 valves
4 valves
Posts: 843
Joined: Wed Dec 14, 2011 9:10 am
Location: Tewksbury, NJ

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by hup_d_dup »

I believe that in the US, the switch to CC tubas was done for largely the same reasons that it was done with trumpets, but it happened with trumpets first. Georges Mager, who was principle trumpet at the Boston Symphony from 1919 to 1950, was the first principal player to adopt instruments in C as the primary instrument. (This largely pre-dates Bill Bell and Arnold Jacobs). Mager's students included Adolf Herseth, Roger Voisin and Bernard Adelstein - each of whom was hugely influential in the symphonic world, at least on this side of the Atlantic.

Hup
Do you really need Facebook?
User avatar
Wyvern
Wessex Tubas
Wessex Tubas
Posts: 5033
Joined: Fri Sep 01, 2006 7:00 pm
Location: Hampshire, England when not travelling around the world on Wessex business
Contact:

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by Wyvern »

obreitys wrote:Just out of curiosity, would any of you gurus happen to know exactly *why* we have the big split between CC in North American orchestra and BBb in Europe?
It is really only in Eastern Europe where the BBb is mostly used in the orchestra. In Russia BBb is the main orchestral tuba. In much of Europe F is the main orchestral tuba, with CC used as contrabass. In Germany it is F and BBb. In the UK it is today mostly Eb and CC - but up until 1960’s it was F tubas.

It is interesting the regional differences even today.
Ace
5 valves
5 valves
Posts: 1395
Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 12:46 am
Location: Berkeley, CA

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by Ace »

hup_d_dup wrote:I believe that in the US, the switch to CC tubas was done for largely the same reasons that it was done with trumpets, but it happened with trumpets first. Georges Mager, who was principle trumpet at the Boston Symphony from 1919 to 1950, was the first principal player to adopt instruments in C as the primary instrument. (This largely pre-dates Bill Bell and Arnold Jacobs). Mager's students included Adolf Herseth, Roger Voisin and Bernard Adelstein - each of whom was hugely influential in the symphonic world, at least on this side of the Atlantic.

Hup
Thanks Hup. Your post reminds me of a pleasant experience I had in 1953 when I attended a concert of the touring Boston Symphony performing in the cavernous Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles. As I approached the ticket office I encountered a trumpet player standing around chatting with arriving concertgoers. Friendly guy. He was asked about his beautiful instrument and he identified it as a Courtois C trumpet. Said these had been standard in the orchestra for many years. By the way, the great Roger Voisin was playing principal trumpet that evening.

Ace
EdFirth
4 valves
4 valves
Posts: 583
Joined: Sun Mar 21, 2004 7:03 am

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by EdFirth »

Herb Wekselblatt was still using a Sander Bb in the Met orchestra when I took with him in 1973. He was curious about Mirafones and was going to order two, pick a winner, and let me buy the other one at his cost. Unfortunately his wife became very ill and before the horns came she passed away and I got out of the Army. But years later, while in Tampa with the circus I had to visit a repair shop where the repair guy told me a story about spending hours cutting on a Mirafone for him. He also, at the time I was going to him for lessons, told me that he had a little four valve Olds tuba(99?) that he would pull out when the conductor asked "for the F tuba". Ed
The Singing Whale
User avatar
swillafew
5 valves
5 valves
Posts: 1029
Joined: Sun Nov 22, 2009 6:20 pm
Location: Aurora, IL

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by swillafew »

Because of Bill Bell and Arnold Jacobs. They were both "orchestra tuba titans" who held a lot of sway in the tuba community.
I heard that as well (many years ago), that by requiring a C instrument, Bill Bell turned a generation of players that way. According to the version of the story I heard, it ensured nobody played anything but high quality horn, and thus the requirement.
MORE AIR
User avatar
iiipopes
Utility Infielder
Utility Infielder
Posts: 8556
Joined: Tue Sep 06, 2005 1:10 am

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by iiipopes »

bloke wrote:
Heavy_Metal wrote:
You forgot:

Kirk vs. Picard

Ginger vs. Mary Ann

Daphne vs. Velma
Trixie vs. Bubbles
Coke vs. Pepsi
Jupiter JTU1110, RT-82.
"Real" Conn 36K.
User avatar
BrassedOn
bugler
bugler
Posts: 115
Joined: Sun Aug 19, 2018 10:00 am
Location: Texas

Re: Origins of the Great Divide

Post by BrassedOn »

Sweet tea vs unsweet.

Which always cracks me up that plain iced tea is a
negatively marked case, as if the sugar was removed.
BBb bass in orchestra is the unsweet tea of the tuba world.

In the euphonium world,
Cheapo horn (+decent, dependable used car)
vs Premium horn (+motor scooter)
"Do less, better."
19xx? Blessing Sousaphone BBb
1970s King 3b Silver Sonic
1976 Fender Precision bass
Post Reply