Any concept that was CREATED by humans is much easier to define.
My contribution to the thread was not to crap on it. My intent was to contribute to it. I consider this particular definition to be rather simple, and I wanted to point that out.
I never said anything here was "hurting" me, nor that i "didnt care for it."
I once knew someone who thought that the definition of "transposition," or "to transpose" could possibly have a different meaning than is accepted. Specifically, she thought that when a tuba student learns a new horn--say, when they are learning F tuba for the first time, that he/she is "transposing" to use the correct fingerings. I told her this is undeniably false. If you look at a C, and you play a C... then you ARE NOT transposing, regardless of the fingering you use. I told her that to tell a student otherwise would be teaching him/her incorrectly. By the end, she still didnt agree with me. But, she was wrong, I was right, and that's all that matters to me.
Sorry for the slight tangent, but that part of my past is why this thread interested me.
)
