[quote="mexicantuba"]If Al is rocking a 188 in the Phil, I think hes the only one on the planet that would have the guts to do it.
Im sure I have never heard an orchestra recording where I was like "wow amazing!", and someone was playing a miraphone of any stripe.
Orchestra tuba in the US is about york sounding rich tubas. The 188 would sound amazing in Amsterdam however. Or LA. (cue Roger Bobo reference)[/quote
Couple years in this forum and I have observed some pretty whacky statements.
This one is right up there ....
I remember this guy there who used to sound absolutely incredible on his rotary valved 5/4 frankenhorn, until he had to build the absolute biggest and most freeblowing 6/4 piston tuba made.
MartyNeilan wrote:I remember this guy there who used to sound absolutely incredible on his rotary valved 5/4 frankenhorn, until he had to build the absolute biggest and most freeblowing 6/4 piston tuba made.
MartyNeilan wrote:I remember this guy there who used to sound absolutely incredible on his rotary valved 5/4 frankenhorn, until he had to build the absolute biggest and most freeblowing 6/4 piston tuba made.
Wow. Warren played no part in his own downfall (if that's what you mean).
MartyNeilan wrote:I remember this guy there who used to sound absolutely incredible on his rotary valved 5/4 frankenhorn, until he had to build the absolute biggest and most freeblowing 6/4 piston tuba made.
Wow. Warren played no part in his own downfall (if that's what you mean).
Never said that. Just remember liking his Frankenstein sound more when heard from the cheap seats at Avery Fisher, and so did many others.
Weird, I thought you were talking about Baer. I don't know much about his early NY Phil days, but he *did* start as a rotary player and went on to build a 6/4 tuba that fits that description.
Big shoes to fill for the next dude/lady in 30 years or so...
The Baer horn is slightly smaller, not nearly as open, and most likely lighter than the original Deck 6/4 horns.
Joe has been doing an outstanding job of trying to combine the best attributes of both tubas in his personal 6/4 - the bigger bell of the Deck with the tighter front end of the Baer. I don't think anybody is putting heavyweight top & bottom caps on tubas anymore, coupled with the additional weight of the "tone ring" in the bell.