HA! It's been years since I've seen a Miss Swan reference. Great, now I'll have that voice in my head haunting me all day.
Joe, I mostly agree with you, and certainly before I buy or trade anything, I will make that trip and try it for myself. I have tried Neptunes before and liked them, but want to "refresh my memory" with it. However, I think there is still some value to knowing what a specific tuba (or really, a specific *style* of tuba) can sound like in some situation by some player. Plus, it's not as though I own some other 6/4 and I'm trying to tell a lot of details about another 6/4 by a sound clip. I'm just trying to remember or be refreshed about the output of that instrument. I also realize that some great players make awful instruments sound great (and vice versa).
I still stand by my belief that a play test is only good enough to know if you want to take it home. You need a good few weeks or months with an instrument to decide if you really want to keep it.
But yes Miss Swan... it sounds like a tuba.
