Gronitz pf125 and pt10 (rotary)

[Jim Andrus]

Hey all,

I'm wondering if some people would care to give a general comparison of these two horns. I know best is to try them out yourself and I plan to, but I wanted to get just some general ideas on the way they play. Sound color, projection, intonation, low range, high range, etc...

Thanks!

Jim

[tclements]

COMPLETELY different instruments. They sound different, play differently and fulfill 2 completely different needs. Other than they are both in F, they are not at all similar. I would ask: What are YOU looking for in an F tuba?

[Jim Andrus]

I'd say what I'm looking for in an F is a horn that is very versatile and can fulfill lots of different playing needs. Primarily I need a horn that will balance my 2165 in the orchestral setting. I don't want a giant F that will sound too C-like, because to me that defeats the purpose of an F. I've heard that both these horns have a really good F tuba sound, not too heavy or thick.

Secondarily it should also be a really good solo horn, with an interesting sound that projects well. I suppose in the future I will also have need for it to fit well in a brass quintet scenario but for now, I need something that can balance well between orchestra and solo use, and match well with my 2165. Hope that helps.

[tclements]

Then consider the PF.

[Jim Andrus]

Thanks for the recommendation Tony!