Mouthpiece Duplication
-
- bugler
- Posts: 151
- Joined: Mon Jul 13, 2009 12:50 am
- Location: CT
Mouthpiece Duplication
Hello all,
I was wondering if anyone has had a mouthpiece duplicated recently and where they had it done. I know the Houser used to offer that service, but they stopped doing that a while ago, according to their website.
Any info would be much appreciated.
I was wondering if anyone has had a mouthpiece duplicated recently and where they had it done. I know the Houser used to offer that service, but they stopped doing that a while ago, according to their website.
Any info would be much appreciated.
Mirafone 185
Mouthpieces FS/FT
Mouthpieces FS/FT
- bisontuba
- 6 valves
- Posts: 4319
- Joined: Sat Mar 20, 2004 8:55 am
- Location: Bottom of Lake Erie
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
Jim New left Kanstul, but has opened his own shop.YORK-aholic wrote:You might try contacting Kanstul. I seem to think they used to do it...
http://james-r-new.com" target="_blank
Good luck!
Mark
-
- bugler
- Posts: 151
- Joined: Mon Jul 13, 2009 12:50 am
- Location: CT
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
That's good to know. Kanstul's website has a lot of areas, well basically every product but their instrument pages, marked as under construction.bisontuba wrote:Jim New left Kanstul, but has opened his own shop.YORK-aholic wrote:You might try contacting Kanstul. I seem to think they used to do it...
http://james-r-new.com" target="_blank" target="_blank" target="_blank
Good luck!
Mark
As for Mr. New's shop, it looks like he only is producing trumpet mouthpieces, but I will reach out.
Anyone else know of anyone that is doing this? I would like to keep my options open.
Mirafone 185
Mouthpieces FS/FT
Mouthpieces FS/FT
- bort
- 6 valves
- Posts: 11223
- Joined: Wed Sep 22, 2004 11:08 pm
- Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
Stork, in Vermont.
Also, Jim is in the process of moving and setting up his shop in Utah. He told me that once he's up and running, he will be filling a lot of backorders. Didn't sound like a "no" for tuba stuff but more like "not right now."
Also, Jim is in the process of moving and setting up his shop in Utah. He told me that once he's up and running, he will be filling a lot of backorders. Didn't sound like a "no" for tuba stuff but more like "not right now."
- Donn
- 6 valves
- Posts: 5977
- Joined: Fri Aug 19, 2005 3:58 pm
- Location: Seattle, ☯
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
Question - given another production mouthpiece of the same model (but not necessarily made at the same time), and an average one-off copy, which would be less like the original?bloke wrote:Via the miracle of the worldwide web, it's now much more possible (if - ?? - your mouthpiece was ever a "production" mouthpiece) to find another just like it.
-
- bugler
- Posts: 151
- Joined: Mon Jul 13, 2009 12:50 am
- Location: CT
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
Unfortunately, the mouthpiece, a Cooley Helleberg, is out of production and only a small batch was made, so unless I get very lucky on finding another one, duplication is my only real option. And from what I understand, there are two different versions of this mouthpiece from different production runs, which complicates things a bit more. I could be wrong however, as my info is not based on anything other than some forum posts and Googling....bloke wrote:Via the miracle of the worldwide web, it's now much more possible (if - ?? - your mouthpiece was ever a "production" mouthpiece) to find another just like it. Re-plating (a slightly worn found duplicate) is far more available than copying services.
Mirafone 185
Mouthpieces FS/FT
Mouthpieces FS/FT
-
- bugler
- Posts: 151
- Joined: Mon Jul 13, 2009 12:50 am
- Location: CT
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
Thanks for the info, I will reach out to Stork.bort wrote:Stork, in Vermont.
Also, Jim is in the process of moving and setting up his shop in Utah. He told me that once he's up and running, he will be filling a lot of backorders. Didn't sound like a "no" for tuba stuff but more like "not right now."
Mirafone 185
Mouthpieces FS/FT
Mouthpieces FS/FT
-
- 5 valves
- Posts: 1579
- Joined: Sat Mar 20, 2004 11:01 am
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
Dillon Music had a custom mouthpiece maker on staff at one time, maybe they still do. It's certainly a place you could call and ask.
Schilke did custom mouthpiece work on the side for years. Not sure if they still do. It's another place you could call and ask.
Karl Hammond was one of (the?) custom mouthpiece maker at Schilke for years. He now has his own shop. I'm not sure if he's interested in doing duplication, but it's another shop you could ask.
Stork does custom mouthpiece work and claims to do copies on request.
Warburton did a lot of custom mouthpiece work. Not sure if he's interested in doing duplication. Yet another place you could ask.
Bloke's point is certainly something to consider - that is, if the original is a production mouthpiece, it may be cheaper, easier, and less time consuming to just track down another example of that rather than having a custom duplication done.
Schilke did custom mouthpiece work on the side for years. Not sure if they still do. It's another place you could call and ask.
Karl Hammond was one of (the?) custom mouthpiece maker at Schilke for years. He now has his own shop. I'm not sure if he's interested in doing duplication, but it's another shop you could ask.
Stork does custom mouthpiece work and claims to do copies on request.
Warburton did a lot of custom mouthpiece work. Not sure if he's interested in doing duplication. Yet another place you could ask.
Bloke's point is certainly something to consider - that is, if the original is a production mouthpiece, it may be cheaper, easier, and less time consuming to just track down another example of that rather than having a custom duplication done.
The Darling Of The Thirty-Cents-Sharp Low D♭'s.
- bort
- 6 valves
- Posts: 11223
- Joined: Wed Sep 22, 2004 11:08 pm
- Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
Side note: I used to own a Conn Geib, which was the exact mouthpiece that Lee Stofer had in his possession to copy and make his Stofer Geib. I greatly preferred the Conn to the copy. Even if they were identical in dimensions, maybe there was something to the old metal that gave a distinctive "warmth" to the sound.
-
- 3 valves
- Posts: 466
- Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 9:57 pm
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
https://singularityhub.com/2012/09/15/f ... d-scanner/" target="_blank
I'm not sure this is ready for prime time now, but it must have improved in five years.
Probably it should be standard practice for all of us to scan favorite mouthpieces and maintain digital copies for just in case.
I'm not sure this is ready for prime time now, but it must have improved in five years.
Probably it should be standard practice for all of us to scan favorite mouthpieces and maintain digital copies for just in case.
- Donn
- 6 valves
- Posts: 5977
- Joined: Fri Aug 19, 2005 3:58 pm
- Location: Seattle, ☯
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
I think I read here that Warburton was making the Dillon mouthpieces back in the day (years ago), so he might be the obvious suspect if they had a custom option. These days, wouldn't you just send it to China and look for the copy on ebay?Tom wrote:Dillon Music had a custom mouthpiece maker on staff at one time, maybe they still do. It's certainly a place you could call and ask.
...
Warburton did a lot of custom mouthpiece work. Not sure if he's interested in doing duplication. Yet another place you could ask.
I'm going with "not identical dimensions", somewhere in the dark part where you can't really measure, but just to unburden myself of an idea that sprang into my head - what if surface properties have something to do with it? Like, your old mouthpiece had that kind of solid, satiny surface, where the new one was weirdly slippery, and that affects the laminar flow and all that stuff (don't think I know what that means, but it does sound good!) I think the amount of spit and condensation in there is going to make this completely immaterial, but I do think there's something to rim textures.bort wrote:Even if they were identical in dimensions, maybe there was something to the old metal that gave a distinctive "warmth" to the sound.
How am I going to get a good scan of the backbore?timothy42b wrote:Probably it should be standard practice for all of us to scan favorite mouthpieces and maintain digital copies for just in case.
-
- 3 valves
- Posts: 466
- Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 9:57 pm
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
Well doh, slice it open, scan it, weld it back together.Donn wrote:How am I going to get a good scan of the backbore?timothy42b wrote:Probably it should be standard practice for all of us to scan favorite mouthpieces and maintain digital copies for just in case.
Seriously, I don't know the limitations. Maybe it's possible, maybe it's not.
I can think of a work around though. Shooters sometimes use Cerrosafe to make a mold of the inside of a rifle chamber. You could probably do that, pull it out, scan it.
-
- pro musician
- Posts: 223
- Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 2:13 am
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
Garibaldi Musical Instruments in Paramount California.shinytuba7 wrote:Hello all,
I was wondering if anyone has had a mouthpiece duplicated recently and where they had it done. I know the Houser used to offer that service, but they stopped doing that a while ago, according to their website.
Any info would be much appreciated.
(562) 531-8653
No website.
He uses a digital tracer and cnc lathe like Jim New did at Kanstul.
A former student of mine had them make several copies of one of my mouthpieces and it was a very close copy.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A2WZHvui4MI" target="_blank" target="_blank
Norm Pearson
-
- 3 valves
- Posts: 466
- Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 9:57 pm
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
It seems likely to me that if you had a good digital scan of your favorite mouthpiece, and needed to replace it for whatever reason, you could email the file to anybody with a CNC lathe and get a pretty close copy.
-
- pro musician
- Posts: 115
- Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2004 12:52 am
- Location: Eastern Connecticut
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
Josef Klier made the original Cooley Hellebergs, and they will still make them on special order. I just got one in April after emailing Maximilian though their website contact form. The 'piece is labeled JK F.C. 8.0.
The pricing was very reasonable too (around $130 after shipping with the current exchange rate).
Hope this helps
The pricing was very reasonable too (around $130 after shipping with the current exchange rate).
Hope this helps
Steve Lamb
U.S. Coast Guard Band
Rhode Island Philharmonic
U.S. Coast Guard Band
Rhode Island Philharmonic
-
- 3 valves
- Posts: 466
- Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 9:57 pm
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
Now I'm having second thoughts about digitizing.
And maybe this applies to the standard methods.
I wouldn't dream of photocopying someone's creative work and reproducing it. That's theft, plain and simple, and hurts fellow musicians.
So how does duplicating a mouthpiece differ?
And maybe this applies to the standard methods.
I wouldn't dream of photocopying someone's creative work and reproducing it. That's theft, plain and simple, and hurts fellow musicians.
So how does duplicating a mouthpiece differ?
-
- bugler
- Posts: 151
- Joined: Mon Jul 13, 2009 12:50 am
- Location: CT
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
I did not know that. That's probably the best option for me looking at prices. I will get in touch with them. Thanks!tubalamb wrote:Josef Klier made the original Cooley Hellebergs, and they will still make them on special order. I just got one in April after emailing Maximilian though their website contact form. The 'piece is labeled JK F.C. 8.0.
The pricing was very reasonable too (around $130 after shipping with the current exchange rate).
Hope this helps
Mirafone 185
Mouthpieces FS/FT
Mouthpieces FS/FT
-
- 3 valves
- Posts: 466
- Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 9:57 pm
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
Not a tuba one, but I know of people doing trombone and trumpet mouthpieces.Casca Grossa wrote:Does anyone have experience with 3D printing a plastic one? I have 3 expensive mouthpieces that I like a lot and have not found a plastic mouthpiece on the market that I enjoy using. I have played a few marching gigs since I started playing again and would love to make a copy of one of mine for marching gigs. Any advice would be appreciated.
Check out this guy's designs
https://www.thingiverse.com/pieterbos82/designs" target="_blank
I mention him because he uses a parametric rather than explicit CAD software.
-
- 3 valves
- Posts: 466
- Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 9:57 pm
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
The site I linked to is Thingiverse.
It has 3D files already made for an incredible number of designs.
At the local library, I don't see the kids using CAD software to draw their own. They download these designs and print them - minions, pokemons, etc. Many libraries have free 3D printers now. In my town the middle school has one.
But you can make your own designs. TinkerCAD is online and widely used. 123Design is an Autodesk (maker of AutoCAD) product, free download. That's what I've been playing with but for me the learning curve is a bit steep. Engineering school was a lot of decades ago. Pieter uses OpenSCAD which is more useful because you can easily tweak dimensions, but it's also a bit harder to learn.
It has 3D files already made for an incredible number of designs.
At the local library, I don't see the kids using CAD software to draw their own. They download these designs and print them - minions, pokemons, etc. Many libraries have free 3D printers now. In my town the middle school has one.
But you can make your own designs. TinkerCAD is online and widely used. 123Design is an Autodesk (maker of AutoCAD) product, free download. That's what I've been playing with but for me the learning curve is a bit steep. Engineering school was a lot of decades ago. Pieter uses OpenSCAD which is more useful because you can easily tweak dimensions, but it's also a bit harder to learn.
-
- lurker
- Posts: 5
- Joined: Wed Jun 21, 2017 3:56 pm
Re: Mouthpiece Duplication
That guy would be me. I should say it's not completely my design, I just improved the code for a smoother more detailed result, added prettier outer shapes and modeled my favorite big band bass trombone mouthpiece, with some small changes. Thingiverse lists that it's a remix of another one made by someone called ckirby.timothy42b wrote:Not a tuba one, but I know of people doing trombone and trumpet mouthpieces.Casca Grossa wrote:Does anyone have experience with 3D printing a plastic one? I have 3 expensive mouthpieces that I like a lot and have not found a plastic mouthpiece on the market that I enjoy using. I have played a few marching gigs since I started playing again and would love to make a copy of one of mine for marching gigs. Any advice would be appreciated.
Check out this guy's designs
https://www.thingiverse.com/pieterbos82/designs" target="_blank" target="_blank" target="_blank
I mention him because he uses a parametric rather than explicit CAD software.
I'm currently designing a few tuba pieces, based on shapes I found online. I made a pt-65-ish piece that plays very easily. Printed in pink
Now working on a more cup, less funnel shaped one, it might be like a miraphone c4 but I'm not so sure because I don't have one. They are not parametric - I could have done that, but I wanted to try a different approach.
I might share them later, or send me a message if you want them.
also a parametric trombone design, and a parametric practice mute that can be adapted for any brass instrument, see thingiverse.
The trombone design is flexible enough to also be changed into even a baroque trombone. I still need to test that